Best Hooks for Pier Fishing: Circle, Kahle, Baitholder and Bait Rigs

8 min read

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Read our affiliate disclosure.

The short answer

For shrimp on the bottom, the Eagle Claw Lazer Sharp Kahle; for catching your own live bait, the Hayabusa Sabiki S-002AE; for pompano and whiting you plan to release, the Sea Striker Circle Hook Pompano Rig.

Our verdict

Pier Fishing Hook Top Picks

Ken Jones of Pier Fishing in California writes that most pier anglers need only a few hook types, picked by bait. Here are eight: three bottom-bait hooks, two sabikis, two pompano rigs and a king mackerel rig, each linked at the exact size and pack. For heavier offshore hooks, see our saltwater hook guide; for rods and reels, our fishing gear guides.

Related guide: Best Submersible Green Fishing Lights for Docks and Boats

Pier hook finder

Find a pier hook or rig for your job

Pick the job and a price tier per pack. The suggestion is our editorial starting point among the eight hooks and rigs below, drawn from the maker pages and sources cited in each review, not a test result.

What are you fishing for?
Price tier

Tiers are relative to the picks in this guide; live prices are in the comparison table below.

Compare the picks

Compare the 8 Pier Hooks and Rigs

Sizes are the makers’; Hayabusa’s are Japanese sizes.

Gamakatsu Circle Offset Point Octopus Hook-Pack Of 25…Gamakatsu Offset Octopus CircleOffset Bait CircleBottom bait, catch and releaseOffset circle$19.49
Hook size2/0
Hooks per pack25
FinishNS Black

Evidence: owner reports, no independent test

EAGLE CLAW Lazer Sharp KAHLE Offset, Bronze, 1/0…Eagle Claw Lazer Sharp KahleWide-Gap KahleShrimp, cut bait, flounderOffset Kahle$13.75
Hook size1/0
Hooks per pack40
FinishBronze

Evidence: owner reports, no independent test

Mustad Beak Baitholder Hook Bronze Long Shank 92641 Size…Mustad 92641 Beak BaitholderLong-Shank Baitholder JCut bait, crabs, wormsBaitholder J$11.79
Hook size1/0
Hooks per pack50
FinishBronze

Evidence: owner reports, no independent test

Hayabusa S-002AE Hage Fish Skin SABIKI Rig (4)Hayabusa Sabiki S-002AEFish-Skin SabikiCatching live baitFish-skin sabiki$8.95
Hook size4
Hooks per pack6
FinishGold

Evidence: owner reports, no independent test

Owner 5528-017 Dancing Hook Sabiki Gold 10Owner Gold Dancing Sabiki 5528-017Flat-Shank SabikiCatching live baitFlat-shank sabiki$8.58
Hook size10
Hooks per pack6
FinishGold

Evidence: owner reports, no independent test

Sea Striker SMP1 Number 6 Spot, Kingfish and Pompano…Sea Striker SMP1 Pompano RigWide-Gap Pompano RigPompano, spot, whitingTwo-drop rig$8.10 Prime
Hook size#6
Hooks per pack2
FinishPlated

Evidence: maker specs only, no independent test

Sea Striker Double Drop Spot, Kingfish & Pompano Rig with…Sea Striker Circle Hook Pompano RigCircle-Hook Pompano RigPompano, spot, whitingTwo-drop circle rig$9.74
Hook size#1
Hooks per pack2
FinishNot published

Evidence: maker specs only, no independent test

Sea Striker K2T-SIL Carolina Live Bait King Rig #5 Solid…Sea Striker K2T-SIL King RigSlow-Troll King RigKing mackerel, live baitWire rig with trebles$8.08 Prime
Hook size2/0 nose hook
Hooks per pack3
FinishBronze

Evidence: maker specs only, no independent test

Prices as of Nov 18, 20:58 UTC

How We Chose Pier Hooks and Rigs

How this guide was built

built from manufacturer documentation, a pier-fishing forum guide, a tackle shop’s pier guide and owner reports; we have not tested these products ourselves.

What each pick had to show

  • A pier job named by its maker or a named source.
  • Size, finish and pack count as the maker lists them; “not published” where it gives none.
  • An exact Amazon listing, read on the day of writing for stock and seller.

The Tackle Room, quoted on rigs, is a tackle shop, not an independent tester; no source tested these exact packs.

Pier Hooks and Rigs: Detailed Reviews

Gamakatsu Offset Octopus Circle, Offset Bait Circle

Verdict

A 2/0 offset circle for bait left on the bottom.

Evidence: No independent test; owner reports. Pier Fishing in California (Ken Jones): Gamakatsu circle hooks, model not stated.

Gamakatsu designs it “to set in the corner of a fishes mouth.” Ken Jones says pier board circle favorites “included Owner, Gamakatsu, and Eagle Claw” (no model named). Sold by SUPER DEALS!, a third-party seller, at the time of writing.

Specs (linked: 2/0, 25 hooks)

    Pros

    • Offset circle Gamakatsu designs to set in the corner of the mouth

    Cons

    • No wire gauge published

    Who should buy it

    Anglers soaking bait who release most fish.

    Check on Amazon

    • NS Black, offset point (Gamakatsu); wire not published
    • Price tier: $$$ (live Amazon price in the table above)

    Eagle Claw Lazer Sharp Kahle, Wide-Gap Kahle

    Wide-Gap Kahle

    Verdict

    A wide-gap shrimp hook in a pier writer’s size.

    Evidence: No independent test; owner reports. Pier Fishing in California (Ken Jones): Eagle Claw Kahle, 1/0 to 2/0.

    For ghost shrimp Ken Jones wants a longer shank and a wide-open gap: “My favorite here is a Eagle Claw Kahle (the best) in 1/0 to 2/0 sizes.” Eagle Claw lists 40 per pack; our channel catfish hook guide links this Kahle at 2/0. Sold by Forza Sports at the time of writing.

    Specs (linked: L141FH-1/0, 1/0, 40 hooks)

      Pros

      • Long shank and wide gap for threading shrimp, as Ken Jones describes

      Cons

      • Priced well above Eagle Claw’s list at the time of writing

      Who should buy it

      Anglers threading shrimp for flounder or sea trout.

      Check on Amazon

      • Bronze, offset (Eagle Claw); wire not published
      • Price tier: $$ (live Amazon price in the table above)

      Mustad 92641 Beak Baitholder, Long-Shank Baitholder J

      Long-Shank Baitholder J

      Verdict

      A barbed-shank J hook for cut bait and crabs.

      Evidence: No independent test; owner reports. Pier Fishing in California (Ken Jones): Mustad 92641 or 92642, size not stated.

      Mustad calls it “Great with rag worms, crabs and fish chunks depending on the size of hook.” Ken Jones: “For most pier angling I use baitholder hooks,” naming “Mustad Bait Gripper 92641 or 92642.” Our freshwater hook guide links an Eagle Claw baitholder instead. Sold by Authorized Tackle Distribution (shipped by Amazon) at the time of writing.

      Specs (linked: 92641-BR-1/0-50, 1/0, 50 hooks)

        Pros

        • Shank slices that hold bait in position, per Mustad

        Cons

        • Ken Jones notes shank barbs can deter catch-and-release anglers

        Who should buy it

        Bottom anglers with cut bait who keep fish.

        Check on Amazon

        • Bronze, long shank with slices, reversed beak point, forged (Mustad)
        • Price tier: $$ (live Amazon price in the table above)

        Hayabusa Sabiki S-002AE Hage Fish Skin, Fish-Skin Sabiki

        Fish-Skin Sabiki
        Hayabusa S-002AE Hage Fish Skin SABIKI Rig (4)

        Hayabusa Sabiki S-002AE

        Size 4

        Anglers catching sardines or menhaden for live bait.

        $8.95 from AmazonAs of Nov 18, 20:58 UTC

        Verdict

        A six-hook fish-skin sabiki for jigging up bait.

        Evidence: No independent test; owner reports. r/Fishing: Hayabusa sabiki, model not stated.

        Hayabusa lists size 4 with “6 Hooks – 13(lb) Mono Main Line – 7(lb) Mono Branch Line.” A poster in an r/Fishing thread started on a Florida pier: “I use Hayabusa sabiki rigs most the time as they are super cheap” (model not stated). Sold by The Jogger’s Corner (shipped by Amazon) at the time of writing.

        Specs (linked: S-002AE, size 4, 6 hooks)

          Pros

          • Six fish-skin hooks on 13 lb main line, per Hayabusa

          Cons

          • Light 7 lb branch lines

          Who should buy it

          Anglers catching sardines or menhaden for live bait.

          Check on Amazon

          • 13 lb main line, 7 lb branch lines, gold hooks (Hayabusa); high-carbon steel (Amazon listing)
          • Price tier: $ (live Amazon price in the table above)

          Owner Gold Dancing Sabiki 5528-017, Flat-Shank Sabiki

          Flat-Shank Sabiki

          Verdict

          A small-hook sabiki with flattened gold shanks.

          Evidence: No independent test; owner reports. r/Fishing: Owner Dancing Hook sabiki, size not stated.

          Owner: “With a shank pressed flat, the gold hooks ‘dance’ down the water column.” In the same thread a poster writes: “I’ve had good luck with the dancing hooks by owner. Caught many threadfin and greenbacks with it.” Sold by NightGalaxy (shipped by Amazon) at the time of writing.

          Hayabusa or Owner? Hayabusa: size 4 fish-skin hooks. Owner: size 10 hooks, heavier branch lines.

          Specs (linked: 5528-017, size 10, 6 hooks)

            Pros

            • Flattened shanks Owner says make the hooks “dance”

            Cons

            • Above Owner’s list price at the time of writing

            Who should buy it

            Anglers jigging for small baitfish such as threadfin.

            Check on Amazon

            • 15 lb main line, 10 lb branch lines, gold hooks (Owner)
            • Price tier: $ (live Amazon price in the table above)

            Sea Striker SMP1 Pompano Rig, Wide-Gap Pompano Rig

            Wide-Gap Pompano Rig
            Sea Striker SMP1 Number 6 Spot, Kingfish and Pompano…

            Sea Striker SMP1 Pompano Rig

            #6

            Anglers fishing shrimp for spot, whiting and pompano.

            $8.10 from AmazonAs of Nov 18, 20:58 UTC

            Verdict

            A pre-tied two-hook bottom rig.

            Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: Sea Striker SMP1 page.

            Sea Striker: “A double rig for all small to medium game fish. Mono rig has #6 plated wide gap hooks with red beads.” Its option label says #2; its text and the Amazon listing say #6. The Tackle Room, a tackle shop, says its two-dropper bottom rig “catches pompano, whiting, croaker, spot, black drum, and flounder.” For baits, see our baits for ocean fishing.

            Specs (linked: SMP1, #6, 2 hooks)

              Pros

              • Pre-tied two-drop rig with #6 wide gap hooks, per Sea Striker

              Cons

              • About four times Sea Striker’s list price at the time of writing

              Who should buy it

              Anglers fishing shrimp for spot, whiting and pompano.

              Check on Amazon

              • Mono, two drops, red beads, no float (Sea Striker, Amazon listing)
              • Price tier: $ (live Amazon price in the table above)

              Sea Striker Circle Hook Pompano Rig, Circle-Hook Pompano Rig

              Circle-Hook Pompano Rig
              Sea Striker Double Drop Spot, Kingfish & Pompano Rig with…

              Sea Striker Circle Hook Pompano Rig

              #1

              Anglers releasing most of their pompano and whiting.

              $9.74 from AmazonAs of Nov 18, 20:58 UTC

              Verdict

              The same two-drop layout, tied with circle hooks.

              Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: Sea Striker circle hook rig page.

              Sea Striker says the rig carries Eagle Claw Lazer Sharp circle hooks; we link the #1 with red beads. The Tackle Room says circles on its bottom rig “reduce gut-hooking and improve release survival,” citing 1/0 to 3/0. Sold by Fishermen’s Source at the time of writing.

              SMP1 or circle rig? SMP1: #6 wide gap hooks. This one: #1 circles for release.

              Specs (linked: red beads, #1, 2 hooks)

                Pros

                • Eagle Claw Lazer Sharp circle hooks, per Sea Striker

                Cons

                • #1 circles are smaller than the sizes The Tackle Room cites
                • Priced well above Sea Striker’s list at the time of writing

                Who should buy it

                Anglers releasing most of their pompano and whiting.

                Check on Amazon

                • Eagle Claw Lazer Sharp circles (Sea Striker); finish not published
                • Price tier: $ (live Amazon price in the table above)

                Sea Striker K2T-SIL King Rig, Slow-Troll King Rig

                Slow-Troll King Rig

                Verdict

                A wire live-bait rig for king mackerel.

                Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: Sea Striker king rig page.

                Sea Striker: “The nose hook is a live bait size 2/0. Treble hooks are 4X Eagle Claw size 4.” The maker says coated wire; the Amazon description says uncoated. The Tackle Room on the king slow-troll rig: “This is pier-specific.” It rigs a Trokar hook, not this rig.

                Specs (linked: K2T-SIL, 2/0 nose hook, 3 hooks)

                  Pros

                  • Nose hook plus two 4X treble stingers, per Sea Striker

                  Cons

                  • Maker and listing disagree on whether the wire is coated

                  Who should buy it

                  Anglers slow-trolling live bait for king mackerel.

                  Check on Amazon

                  • Bronze hooks snelled with 60 lb wire, two #4 trebles (Sea Striker)
                  • Price tier: $ (live Amazon price in the table above)

                  Circle or J Hooks Off a Pier

                  Ken Jones: “The largest determinant for hooks is the size and type of bait you will be using.” He writes that circle hooks are the choice of many catch-and-release anglers, with anglers reporting up to 95% of fish hooked in the lips; he uses J-style baitholder hooks for most pier angling and a Kahle for ghost shrimp. Check your local hook rules. For rig layouts, see how to rig a fishing rod.

                  Circle hook and J hook side by side
                  Illustration: a circle hook beside a J hook, the two shapes compared

                  Frequently Asked Questions

                  Q. What hooks should I use for pier fishing?

                  Ken Jones names baitholder, Kahle, live bait and circle hooks, chosen by bait size and type.

                  Q. What is the best rig for fishing off a pier?

                  The Tackle Room calls its two-dropper bottom rig “The workhorse.”

                  Q. What are the must-haves for pier fishing?

                  The Tackle Room says to pack extra sinkers, hooks, swivels and leader, since snags and toothy fish take rigs.

                  Q. What is the best way to fish from a pier?

                  The Tackle Room calls live shrimp “the universal pier bait” and says “Caught-your-own live bait is the key to king mackerel fishing.”

                  The bottom line

                  Final Verdict

                  Shrimp: the Eagle Claw Lazer Sharp Kahle (check price). Cut bait: the Mustad 92641 Beak Baitholder (check price). Release: the Gamakatsu Offset Octopus Circle (check price). Catching bait: the Hayabusa Sabiki S-002AE (check price) or the Owner Gold Dancing Sabiki 5528-017 (check price). Pompano and whiting: the Sea Striker SMP1 Pompano Rig (check price), or the Sea Striker Circle Hook Pompano Rig (check price) for release. Kings: the Sea Striker K2T-SIL King Rig (check price).

                  Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

                  Outgearly Team
                  Outgearly Team

                  Written and reviewed by the Outgearly Team. See the About page for how we work.