Best Worms to Fish With: Live Worms by Type, Plus Preserved and Scented Baits

12 min read

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Read our affiliate disclosure.

The short answer

For a big live worm for walleye, catfish and bass, BESTBAIT Canadian Nightcrawlers; for bluegill, crappie and perch, Uncle Jim’s Worm Farm Red Wigglers; for waxworms that keep in a tackle box, Eurotackle Mummy Worm.

Our verdict

Worms to Fish With: Top Picks

The worm farms that rank for this question answer it by type: nightcrawlers for bigger fish, red worms and mealworms for small mouths, waxworms for ice and panfish. So do we. Here are nine on Amazon: five live packs, one preserved waxworm and three scented imitations, each linked at the exact count or size. Soft plastic lures are in our soft plastic bass worms roundup and fake worms roundup; the rest is in our fishing gear guides.

Related guide: Best Bass Lures for Night Fishing: Topwaters, Spinnerbaits, Worms and Jigs

Related guide: 10 Best Saltwater Fishing Baits: Scented Strips, Soft Shrimp, Crabs and Gel

Worm finder

Find a worm for the fish you're after

Pick your fish and a price tier per pack. The suggestion is our editorial starting point among the nine worms below, drawn from the sellers' and makers' pages and the sources cited in each review, not a test result.

What are you fishing for?
Price tier

Tiers are relative to the worms in this guide; live prices are in the comparison table below.

Compare the picks

Compare the 9 Fishing Worms

Figures are the seller’s or maker’s (“Listing”: the Amazon listing; “Not published”: neither gives it); “Best for” follows each review’s sources.

BESTBAIT 50 Count Canadian Nightcrawlers (4-6 inch)…BESTBAIT Canadian NightcrawlersLarge Live NightcrawlerWalleye, catfish, bassLive nightcrawler$39.99
Linked pack50 count, 4-6 in
SizeListing: 4-6 in
Count50
FormLive

Evidence: BESTBAIT listing and site only; no independent review

Uncle Jim's Worm Farm European Nightcrawlers Composting and…Uncle Jim's Worm Farm European NightcrawlersEuropean NightcrawlerBass, walleye, catfishLive European nightcrawler$49.95
Linked pack1 lb pack
SizeBed run, mixed
CountNot published
FormLive

Evidence: Uncle Jim's own guide and listing; it sells these worms; no independent review

Uncle Jim's Worm Farm 100 Count Red Wiggler Composting…Uncle Jim's Worm Farm Red WigglersSmall Live Red WormBluegill, crappie, perchLive red wiggler mix$28.99
Linked pack100 count
SizeNot published
Count100
FormLive

Evidence: Uncle Jim's own guide and listing; it sells these worms; no independent review

BESTBAIT 100 Count Live Giant Mealworms for Fishing Bait &…BESTBAIT Giant MealwormsLive MealwormTrout, perch, ice fishingLive mealworm$18.99
Linked pack100 count
SizeNot published
Count100
FormLive

Evidence: BESTBAIT listing only; mealworm uses from Uncle Jim's type guide

Dubia.com 100 Live Waxworms Worms, HighProtein Wax Worms…Dubia.com Live WaxwormsLive WaxwormPanfish, trout, ice fishingLive waxworm$8.60
Linked pack100 count
SizeNot published
Count100
FormLive

Evidence: Dubia.com listing only; waxworm uses from Uncle Jim's type guide

Mummy Worm Natural - 35 Wax Worms - Preserved Live Bait…Eurotackle Mummy WormPreserved Wax WormTrout, panfish, ice fishingPreserved waxworm$5.99
Linked packNatural, 35 count
SizeNot published
CountListing: 35
FormPreserved

Evidence: TenkaraBum sold them when it wrote this and no longer carries them; text covers pink and brown, one caption shows Natural

Berkley Gulp! Sandworm Camo, 6 InchBerkley Gulp! Saltwater SandwormScented SandwormSurf, perch, halibutScented sandworm$8.01 Prime
Linked packCamo, 6 in
Size6 in
CountNot published
FormImitation

Evidence: SC Surf Fishing, Gulp! sandworm in four colours incl. camo; length not stated; undated

Berkley PowerBait Power Nightcrawler Natural, 6" (13 Count)Berkley PowerBait Power NightcrawlerScented Plastic CrawlerWalleye, spinner rigsScented plastic worm$5.17 Prime
Linked packNatural, 6 in, 13 count
Size6 in
Count13
FormImitation

Evidence: Berkley specs; one East Tennessee Fishing forum poster (2011) prefers it on walleye spinner rigs

Fishbites Bag O' Worms Bloodworm - Longer Lasting (3/8"…Fishbites Bag O' Worms BloodwormSynthetic BloodwormSaltwater, panfishSynthetic bloodworm$8.95
Linked packLonger Lasting, Red, 3/8 in
Size3/8 x 12 in
Count2
FormImitation

Evidence: Fishing At Work, Bag O' Worms bloodworm with mesh; width not stated

Prices as of Nov 19, 00:08 UTC

How We Chose These Worms

How this guide was built

built from sellers’ and makers’ listings, worm-farm guides, published reviews and angler forum posts; we have not tested these products ourselves.

What each worm had to show

  • A fishing use named by the seller, the maker or a cited angler.
  • The count or size on the listing, in stock and new on Amazon on the day of writing.
  • One pick per bait type, except nightcrawlers, where two sellers ship two different worms.
Sources and their limits

Sources and their limits

We found no independent review of any live pack. Uncle Jim’s Worm Farm and Memes Worms, whose guides we quote, sell worms. Each live pack ships from its seller. All three sellers (BESTBAIT, Uncle Jim’s, Dubia.com) state live-arrival guarantees on their own sites; that wording covers orders there, so check the Amazon order’s terms.

Fishing Worms: Detailed Reviews

Picks: Canadian Nightcrawlers, European Nightcrawlers, Red Wigglers, Mealworms, Waxworms, Mummy Worm, Gulp! Sandworm, Power Nightcrawler, Bag O’ Worms.

BESTBAIT Canadian Nightcrawlers, Large Live Nightcrawler

Large Live Nightcrawler
BESTBAIT 50 Count Canadian Nightcrawlers (4-6 inch)…

BESTBAIT Canadian Nightcrawlers

50 Count

Anglers after walleye, catfish or bass who will use 50 worms before they spoil.

$39.99 from AmazonAs of Nov 19, 00:08 UTC

Verdict

Full-size live nightcrawlers, 50 to a pack, from a live-bait seller that names walleye, catfish and bass.

Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: BESTBAIT (seller and producer).

BESTBAIT’s listing says the worms “range from 4 to 6 inches” and “work effectively for catching walleye, catfish, panfish, trout, and bass.” The listing names no bedding, and it and BESTBAIT’s product page disagree on care: the listing says they “require no refrigeration,” the site says “Store in a refrigerated location.” Amazon’s customer-review summary: “The survival rate is mixed, with some customers reporting all worms arrived alive while others received many dead or stressed ones.”

Canadian or European? BESTBAIT’s come counted and sized; Uncle Jim’s come by the pound, sizes mixed.

Specs (linked: 50 count, 4-6 in)

    Pros

    • Counted, sized nightcrawlers sold as fishing bait, per the listing
    • Sold and shipped by BESTBAIT itself

    Cons

    • Survival in shipping is mixed, per Amazon’s review summary
    • Listing and site disagree on refrigeration

    Who should buy it

    Anglers after walleye, catfish or bass who will use 50 worms before they spoil.

    Check on Amazon

    • Length: 4-6 in (listing)
    • Count: 50 (listing)
    • Price tier: $$$ (live price above)

    Uncle Jim’s Worm Farm European Nightcrawlers, European Nightcrawler

    European Nightcrawler
    Uncle Jim's Worm Farm European Nightcrawlers Composting and…

    Uncle Jim's Worm Farm European Nightcrawlers

    1 lb

    Anglers who fish nightcrawlers often and will keep a worm bin going between trips.

    $49.95 from AmazonAs of Nov 19, 00:08 UTC

    Verdict

    A pound of European nightcrawlers from the farm whose guide led our search results, sold for composting and fishing.

    Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: Uncle Jim’s Worm Farm (seller and producer).

    Uncle Jim’s guide: “Many types of nightcrawler worms make excellent fishing worms, including Canadian and European Nightcrawlers.” The listing calls them “2-5 times larger than normal red worms,” from beds that “may contain different earthworm species.” Its site warns anglers: “We can not guarantee all bait size worms upon delivery,” because it ships “bed run,” a mix of mature and young worms. Amazon’s review summary: “some find them big, others say they’re too small for fishing.” Uncle Jim’s site says worms left “in a mail box or a parcel locker for too long” will not survive.

    Specs (linked: 1 lb pack)

      Pros

      • European nightcrawlers Uncle Jim’s names for bass, walleye and catfish

      Cons

      • Not all bait size on arrival, per the seller
      • The listing is written for composting more than fishing

      Who should buy it

      Anglers who fish nightcrawlers often and will keep a worm bin going between trips.

      Check on Amazon

      • Count: not published (sold by weight)
      • Size: bed run, mixed (Uncle Jim’s site)
      • Price tier: $$$ (live price above)

      Uncle Jim’s Worm Farm Red Wigglers, Small Live Red Worm

      Small Live Red Worm
      Uncle Jim's Worm Farm 100 Count Red Wiggler Composting…

      Uncle Jim's Worm Farm Red Wigglers

      100 Count

      Panfish anglers, kids' fishing trips and anyone fishing small hooks.

      $28.99 from AmazonAs of Nov 19, 00:08 UTC

      Verdict

      A hundred small live worms for small mouths.

      Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: Uncle Jim’s Worm Farm (seller and producer).

      Uncle Jim’s guide: “Red wigglers are great bait for smaller fish like bluegill, crappie, sunfish and perch. These fish have small mouths and can’t eat big nightcrawlers consistently.” The listing title names “Garden Soil or Fishing” and says the worms “may contain different earthworm species,” so expect a red worm mix.

      Red wigglers or mealworms? Uncle Jim’s names both for small fish, and mealworms for ice fishing.

      Specs (linked: 100 count)

        Pros

        • A small worm for bluegill, crappie and perch, per the seller’s guide
        • Fishing named in the listing title

        Cons

        • A mix of species, per the listing
        • The seller’s own guide is the only source

        Who should buy it

        Panfish anglers, kids’ fishing trips and anyone fishing small hooks.

        Check on Amazon

        • Count: 100 (listing)
        • Species: red wiggler mix (listing)
        • Price tier: $$ (live price above)

        BESTBAIT Giant Mealworms, Live Mealworm

        Live Mealworm
        BESTBAIT 100 Count Live Giant Mealworms for Fishing Bait &…

        BESTBAIT Giant Mealworms

        100 Count

        Ice anglers and trout fishers who want a small live bait.

        $18.99 from AmazonAs of Nov 19, 00:08 UTC

        Verdict

        A live mealworm for trout and perch, sold mostly as a pet feeder.

        Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: BESTBAIT (seller and producer).

        BESTBAIT calls them “Large, plump mealworms packed fresh” for pets “and fishing bait applications,” “Carefully packed to help maintain freshness and activity during transit.” It gives no length. Uncle Jim’s guide on the type: “Mealworms also work especially well for ice fishing for trout or perch.”

        Specs (linked: Pack of 100)

          Pros

          • Small live bait for trout and perch, per Uncle Jim’s on mealworms

          Cons

          • Written for pet feeding first
          • Size not published

          Who should buy it

          Ice anglers and trout fishers who want a small live bait.

          Check on Amazon

          • Count: 100 (listing variant)
          • Length: not published
          • Price tier: $$ (live price above)

          Dubia.com Live Waxworms, Live Waxworm

          Live Waxworm
          Dubia.com 100 Live Waxworms Worms, HighProtein Wax Worms…

          Dubia.com Live Waxworms

          100 Count

          Ice and panfish anglers who want a live waxie on a small jig or hook.

          $8.60 from AmazonAs of Nov 19, 00:08 UTC

          Verdict

          A hundred live waxworms, the bait Uncle Jim’s calls “The Secret Weapon for Ice Fishing.”

          Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: Dubia.com (seller and producer).

          Dubia.com’s listing says the waxworms are “Sourced from the Greater Wax Moth” and “serve as excellent live worms for fishing.” Uncle Jim’s on the type: “Their soft texture and sweet scent make them irresistible to panfish, trout and crappie.”

          Live waxworms or Mummy Worms? Live waxies move; Mummy Worms keep in a box.

          Specs (linked: 1 Count, Pack of 100)

            Pros

            • A soft bait Uncle Jim’s names for panfish, trout and crappie
            • Sold and shipped by Dubia Roaches, Dubia.com’s storefront

            Cons

            • Low stock at our check
            • Soft bodies can burst; Memes Worms hooks them “just under the head”

            Who should buy it

            Ice and panfish anglers who want a live waxie on a small jig or hook.

            Check on Amazon

            • Count: 100 (listing variant)
            • Species: greater wax moth larva (listing)
            • Price tier: $ (live price above)

            Eurotackle Mummy Worm, Preserved Wax Worm

            Preserved Wax Worm
            Mummy Worm Natural - 35 Wax Worms - Preserved Live Bait…

            Eurotackle Mummy Worm

            Natural 35 Count

            Ice and panfish anglers who want waxies on hand without keeping live ones.

            $5.99 from AmazonAs of Nov 19, 00:08 UTC

            Verdict

            Real waxworms, preserved and coloured, that keep in a tackle box.

            Evidence: Retailer review (sells it), not independent. TenkaraBum: pink and brown in the text; one photo caption shows a brown trout on Natural; 35-40 count container.

            Eurotackle: “Yes They are real wax worm : Mummified wax worm,” preserved to “maintain its characteristics for 2 years,” for “trout, perch, crappie, bluegill, salmon” and ice fishing. The listing says 35 per pack; Eurotackle says “approximately 36.” TenkaraBum, which sold them when it wrote this and no longer does, fished pink and brown: “Because the insides are more waxy than liquid, I think Mummy Worms stay on the hook way better than wax worms.”

            Specs (linked: Natural, 35 count)

              Pros

              • Real waxworms that held on the hook better than live ones for TenkaraBum
              • Sold by Eurotackle’s storefront at its list price at our check

              Cons

              • They do not move like live waxworms
              • The review is by a former retailer, mostly of other colours

              Who should buy it

              Ice and panfish anglers who want waxies on hand without keeping live ones.

              Check on Amazon

              • Count: 35 (listing); about 36 (maker)
              • Shelf life: 2 years (maker); 6 months, 2 years refrigerated (TenkaraBum)
              • Price tier: $ (live price above)

              Berkley Gulp! Saltwater Sandworm, Scented Sandworm

              Scented Sandworm
              Berkley Gulp! Sandworm Camo, 6 Inch

              Berkley Gulp! Saltwater Sandworm

              Camo 6 in

              Surf and pier anglers who want a sandworm without a bait-shop run.

              $8.01 from AmazonAs of Nov 19, 00:08 UTC

              Verdict

              A scented sandworm a Santa Monica surf angler fished for a month, in the camo he thought best.

              Evidence: Independently reviewed, same series. SC Surf Fishing (Marc Cooper): Gulp! saltwater sandworm, four colours including camo; length not stated.

              On SC Surf Fishing, Marc Cooper writes: “I have spent the last month intensively fishing the four colors of the sandworm, mostly in the Santa Monica North area.” He reports perch, a 26-inch halibut and a spotfin croaker, mostly on camo, and hedges: “It seems (but I can’t prove it) that the camo color is the best.” He names no length and wrote when the bait was new. Berkley sells it in 2 in and 6 in. Our ocean bait guide links the 2 in New Penny; here we link the 6 in Camo.

              Specs (linked: Camo, 6 in)

                Pros

                • A surf angler reports perch, halibut and croaker on it
                • Sold by Amazon.com below Berkley’s list price at our check

                Cons

                • The review is undated and names no length
                • A saltwater bait; Berkley names no freshwater use

                Who should buy it

                Surf and pier anglers who want a sandworm without a bait-shop run.

                Check on Amazon

                • Length: 6 in (maker)
                • Count: not published
                • Price tier: $ (live price above)

                Berkley PowerBait Power Nightcrawler, Scented Plastic Crawler

                Scented Plastic Crawler
                Berkley PowerBait Power Nightcrawler Natural, 6" (13 Count)

                Berkley PowerBait Power Nightcrawler

                Natural 6 in

                Walleye trollers running spinner rigs who are tired of rebaiting live crawlers.

                $5.17 from AmazonAs of Nov 19, 00:08 UTC

                Verdict

                A 6 in scented plastic nightcrawler Berkley makes for walleye spinner rigs.

                Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: Berkley (maker).

                Berkley: “Great for trolling on spinner rigs”; it claims fish “hold on 18 times longer,” Berkley’s own figure. On the East Tennessee Fishing forum, a poster writes: “When I use a nightcrawler rig (spinner rig) for walleyes I PREFER Berkley Gulp nightcrawlers or Berkley Power nightcrawler over real nightcrawlers because they stay on the hook better and catch more fish than real nightcrawlers.” He cuts them to 3 or 4 in.

                Plastic or live crawler? The plastic one keeps and, per the poster, stays on the hook; a live one moves.

                Specs (linked: Natural, 6 in, 13 count)

                  Pros

                  • A plastic crawler made for spinner rigs, per Berkley
                  • Sold by Amazon.com below Berkley’s list price at our check

                  Cons

                  • A plastic worm, not a live one
                  • One forum poster from 2011 is the only angler report we found

                  Who should buy it

                  Walleye trollers running spinner rigs who are tired of rebaiting live crawlers.

                  Check on Amazon

                  • Length: 6 in (maker)
                  • Count: 13 (maker)
                  • Price tier: $ (live price above)

                  Fishbites Bag O’ Worms Bloodworm, Synthetic Bloodworm

                  Synthetic Bloodworm
                  Fishbites Bag O' Worms Bloodworm - Longer Lasting (3/8"…

                  Fishbites Bag O' Worms Bloodworm

                  Longer Lasting 3/8 in

                  Bottom and surf anglers who want a bloodworm scent without live bloodworms.

                  $8.95 from AmazonAs of Nov 19, 00:08 UTC

                  Verdict

                  A bloodworm-scented synthetic strip for anglers who would rather not handle live bloodworms.

                  Evidence: Independently reviewed, same series. Fishing At Work: Bag O’ Worms Bloodworm with mesh; width not stated.

                  Fishbites sells the 3/8 in width at 12 in long, “2 baits per pack,” with “Mesh embedded into center of bait” and a “Tear strength = 11”. Fishing At Work fished a mesh Bag O’ Worms bloodworm, width not stated. Its saltwater outing proved nothing, by its own account (“null and void”); in a river, “the panfish love this bait.” It also saw “almost half of the material on the mesh melts away within 20 to 30 minutes.”

                  Bag O’ Worms or Gulp! Sandworm? Bag O’ Worms is a mesh strip cut to length; the Gulp! is worm-shaped, with a surf review behind it.

                  Specs (linked: Longer Lasting, Red, 3/8 in)

                    Pros

                    • A mesh core that holds on the hook, per Fishbites
                    • Sold by Fishbites’ own storefront

                    Cons

                    • About 2% over Fishbites’ list price when we checked
                    • The blog’s one useful report is of river panfish, not saltwater fish

                    Who should buy it

                    Bottom and surf anglers who want a bloodworm scent without live bloodworms.

                    Check on Amazon

                    • Size: 3/8 in wide, 12 in long (maker)
                    • Count: 2 per pack (maker)
                    • Price tier: $ (live price above)

                    Which Worm for Which Fish

                    Freshwater: match the worm to the mouth

                    Uncle Jim’s: “Red worms are smaller, so they’re great for trout and panfish. Nightcrawlers are bigger and better for larger species like bass and catfish.” Hooks are in our hooks for live worms guide; river baits in our river trout baits roundup.

                    Best worms for saltwater fishing

                    Memes Worms names bloodworms (“Attracts striped bass, flounder, and redfish”) and sandworms (“Excellent for surf fishing for flounder, surfperch, and bass”). The shelf-stable stand-ins here are the Gulp! Sandworm and Bag O’ Worms.

                    Fake worms and rubber worms

                    The Power Nightcrawler is the one soft plastic worm here. For Senkos and curly tails fished as lures, see our soft plastic bass worms roundup, which shares no picks with this guide.

                    How to Keep Fishing Worms Alive

                    Uncle Jim’s: “Store your worms in a cool, dark place,” “Keep them moist with a damp paper towel or moss in their container. Don’t add standing water, since it can drown them,” and “Don’t overcrowd the container.” Memes Worms keeps them “between 50–70°F (10–20°C)” at home and in “a small cooler or insulated box” on the water.

                    Small bait cooler of damp bedding with nightcrawlers
                    Illustration: worms kept cool in damp bedding

                    Frequently Asked Questions

                    Q. What is the best worm to fish with?

                    It depends on the fish. Uncle Jim’s: “No single worm is a catch-all for every fishing scenario.” Uncle Jim’s and Memes Worms both name nightcrawlers, red wigglers, mealworms and waxworms; picks 1 to 5 cover all four.

                    Q. Which is better for fishing, red wigglers or nightcrawlers?

                    Uncle Jim’s: “It depends on what and where you’re fishing.” Red worms for trout and panfish, nightcrawlers for bass and catfish.

                    Q. What’s the best way to fish with worms?

                    Memes Worms: “For nightcrawlers, thread 1–2 inches of the body onto the hook and leave the tail dangling for natural movement,” and hook red wigglers “once through the middle.” With a bobber, its float rig is “Great for shallow waters and panfish.” Step by step: how to put a worm on a hook.

                    The bottom line

                    Final Verdict

                    Big fish on live bait: BESTBAIT Canadian Nightcrawlers (check price), or Uncle Jim’s Worm Farm European Nightcrawlers (check price) if you keep a worm bin. Panfish: Uncle Jim’s Worm Farm Red Wigglers (check price). Trout and ice: BESTBAIT Giant Mealworms (check price) or Dubia.com Live Waxworms (check price), with Eurotackle Mummy Worm (check price) for waxies that keep. No live bait: Berkley PowerBait Power Nightcrawler (check price) for walleye spinner rigs and, in saltwater, Berkley Gulp! Saltwater Sandworm (check price) or Fishbites Bag O’ Worms Bloodworm (check price).

                    Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

                    Outgearly Team
                    Outgearly Team

                    Written and reviewed by the Outgearly Team. See the About page for how we work.