Best Fake Worms for Fishing: Soft Plastic and Scented Worms by Type

13 min read

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Read our affiliate disclosure.

The short answer

For wacky and weightless bass fishing, the Yamamoto Senko 5 in; for a scented ribbon-tail on a Texas rig, the Berkley PowerBait Power Worm 7 in; to replace live crawlers under a float or on a spinner rig, the Berkley Gulp! Nightcrawler 6 in.

Our verdict

Fake Worm Top Picks

Fake worms are sold as soft plastic or artificial worms, and they come in several shapes: stick worms that sink on a slack line, ribbon-tails that swim, slim straight-tails for finesse rigs, short ned worms, and scented baits that copy a real nightcrawler. Here are eight, one or two per type, each linked at an exact length, colour and pack. For rods, reels and line, see our fishing gear guides.

Related guide: Best Worms to Fish With: Live Worms by Type, Plus Preserved and Scented Baits

Related guide: Best Fishing Line for Stripers: Braid, Mono and Leaders

Fake worm finder

Find a fake worm for how you fish

Pick how you fish and a price tier. The suggestion is our editorial starting point among the eight worms below, drawn from the sources cited in each review, not a test result.

How do you want to fish it?
Price tier

Tiers are relative to the worms in this guide; live prices are in the comparison table below.

Picks: Senko, YUM Dinger, Power Worm, Ol’ Monster, Roboworm Straight Tail, Finesse TRD, Gulp! Nightcrawler, Gulp! Floating Pinched Crawler

Compare the picks

Compare the 8 Fake Worms

Figures are the maker’s unless a cell names another source.

Yamamoto 5" SENKO JUNE BUG PURPLE W/ EMERALD FLAKE (10 PACK)Yamamoto Senko 5 inSinking Stick WormBass, wacky rig, weightlessStick worm$7.99 Prime
Linked listingJune Bug Purple w/ Emerald Flake
Length5 in
Count10
Key featureSinks

Evidence: r/bassfishing posters; size and colour not stated

Yum Lures 5 Dinger Black, Watermelon pearl, Pack of 30YUM Dinger 5 in 30-packBulk Stick WormBass, wacky rig, texas rigStick worm$11.99 Prime
Linked listingWatermelon/Pearl Laminate
Length5 in
Count30
Key featureHook slot

Evidence: r/bassfishing posters; size and colour not stated

Berkley PowerBait® Power Worm Fishing Bait, Tequila…Berkley PowerBait Power Worm 7 inScented Ribbon-TailBass, texas rigRibbon-tail worm$4.81 Prime
Linked listingTequila Sunrise
Length7 in
CountListing: 13
Key featurePowerBait scent

Evidence: one r/bassfishing poster; Tequila Sunrise, length not stated

Zoom Ol' Monster Bait-Pack of 9 (Junebug, 10.5-Inch)Zoom Ol' Monster 10.5 inMagnum Curl-Tail WormBig bass, carolina rigCurl-tail worm$5.59
Linked listingJunebug
Length10.5 in
Count9
Key featureSalt-impregnated

Evidence: one r/bassfishing poster; colour not stated

Roboworm Straight Tail Worm Bait (Aaron's Magic, 4 1/2-Inch)Roboworm Straight Tail Worm 4.5 inFinesse Straight-TailBass, finesseStraight-tail worm$5.40 Prime
Linked listingAaron's Magic
Length4.5 in
Count10
Key featureSalt release

Evidence: r/bassfishing posters; size and colour not stated

Z-MAN TRD275-316PK8 Finesse TRD Lures, 2 3/4" Length, Green…Z-Man Finesse TRD 2.75 inFloating Ned WormBass, ned rigNed worm$7.49
Linked listingGreen Pumpkin Goby
Length2.75 in
Count8
Key featureFloats

Evidence: r/bassfishing posters on Z-Man ned baits; TRD not named

Berkley Gulp! Nightcrawler Natural, 6-InchBerkley Gulp! Nightcrawler 6 inScented NightcrawlerWalleye, bass, spinner rigsScented nightcrawler$8.99 Prime
Linked listingNatural
Length6 in
Count10
Key featureGulp! scent

Evidence: one r/FishingForBeginners reply; size and colour not stated

Berkley Gulp! Floating Pinched Crawler Nightcrawler, 2-InchBerkley Gulp! Floating Pinched Crawler 2 inFloating Pinched CrawlerTrout, panfishPinched crawler$5.62 Prime
Linked listingNightcrawler, original scent
Length2 in
CountNot published
Key featureFloats; Gulp! scent

Evidence: maker and Amazon listing claims only

Prices as of Nov 18, 21:02 UTC

How We Picked These Fake Worms

How this guide was built

built from manufacturer documentation, published articles and angler reports; we have not tested these products ourselves.

What each worm had to show

  • One worm type per job: stick, ribbon or curl tail, straight tail, ned, or scented crawler, with the rigs its maker lists.
  • Maker specs, checked against the Amazon listing. No maker here publishes a hook size or per-bait weight, so those read “not published”.
  • An exact Amazon listing: length, colour, pack, stock and seller on the day of writing.
Sources and how we graded them and overlap with our other worm guides

Sources and how we graded them

Rigging, hook and sinker advice comes from bassresource’s plastic worm guide. Angler reports come from two ranking threads, r/bassfishing on worm brands and r/FishingForBeginners on artificial worms. We count each poster once and say when a poster names no size or colour. No source here is a lab or field test, so every pick is graded “owner reports” or “maker specs”.

Overlap with our other worm guides

Our bass fishing worms guide picks the Senko 5 in, Power Worm 7 in, Roboworm Straight Tail 4.5 in and YUM Dinger 30-pack in other colours. Our worm colour guide picks the Senko, Dinger and Power Worm in other colours too, and our bait for lakes guide links the same Gulp! Nightcrawler listing. This guide adds the ned worm, the 10.5 in curl-tail and the floating Gulp! for trout and panfish.

Fake Worms for Fishing: Detailed Reviews

Yamamoto Senko 5 in, Sinking Stick Worm

Sinking Stick Worm
Yamamoto 5" SENKO JUNE BUG PURPLE W/ EMERALD FLAKE (10 PACK)

Yamamoto Senko 5 in

Sinking Stick Worm

Anglers wacky-rigging or fishing weightless around docks and shallow cover.

$7.99 from AmazonAs of Nov 19, 00:10 UTC

Verdict

A 5 in stick worm for wacky and weightless rigs, sold by Amazon.com.

Evidence: No independent test; owner reports. r/bassfishing thread: Senko, size and colour not stated.

Yamamoto says the Senko “sinks in water with a tantalizing side-to-side shimmy on a weightless rig” and lists wacky, Texas, drop shot and neko rigs. On r/FishingForBeginners, one poster’s pick for “weightless/whacky style” is “Gary Yamamoto Senko worms.” In the r/bassfishing thread, a poster writes that “The salt content of senkos gives them a better rate of fall than other stick baits, and they have the best wobble on the fall,” but uses them only wacky with an O-ring because “durability is an issue.” Three more replies there say Senkos don’t hold up well. None names a colour.

Specs (linked: June Bug Purple w/ Emerald Flake, 5 in, 10-pack)

    Pros

    • Weightless sinking fall that Yamamoto builds the bait around
    • Purple, a colour family bassresource says “Most professionals use”

    Cons

    • Four replies in one r/bassfishing thread say Senkos don’t hold up well, one on rough cover or toothy fish
    • 10 per bag

    Who should buy it

    Anglers wacky-rigging or fishing weightless around docks and shallow cover.

    Check on Amazon

    • Length: 5 in (Yamamoto)
    • Count: 10 per bag (Yamamoto)
    • Action: sinks with a side-to-side shimmy, weightless (Yamamoto)
    • Hook size: not published
    • Price tier: $$

    YUM Dinger 5 in 30-pack, Bulk Stick Worm

    Bulk Stick Worm
    Yum Lures 5 Dinger Black, Watermelon pearl, Pack of 30

    YUM Dinger 5 in 30-pack

    Bulk Stick Worm

    Anglers who go through stick worms fast on wacky and Texas rigs.

    $11.99 from AmazonAs of Nov 19, 00:10 UTC

    Verdict

    A 5 in stick worm with a hook slot, in a 30-count bag.

    Evidence: No independent test; owner reports. r/bassfishing thread: Dinger, size and colour not stated.

    YUM says the Dinger “can be Texas, Carolina and wacky rigged, weighted or weightless” and has “a unique hook slot that provides better hook-ups.” In the r/bassfishing brand thread, one poster likes YUM “for the hook notch they have. Easiest way to rig it straight.” Another says Dingers catch more bass for him than Senkos because “they stay together longer.” A third still holds that “Nobody makes a better stick bait than Gary Yamamoto Custom Baits.” None names this colour. Amazon’s title for this listing also says “Black”, but the colour field says Watermelon Pearl, the item name adds Laminate, and its model number, YDG5BK74-30, is YUM’s code for the Watermelon/Pearl Laminate 30-pack.

    Specs (linked: Watermelon/Pearl Laminate, 5 in, 30-pack, YDG5BK74-30)

      Pros

      • Hook slot that YUM says improves hook-ups and a poster says helps rig it straight
      • 30 worms per bag

      Cons

      • Top price tier per bag, though the bag holds 30
      • One poster in the same thread still rates Yamamoto’s stick bait above others

      Who should buy it

      Anglers who go through stick worms fast on wacky and Texas rigs.

      Check on Amazon

      • Length: 5 in (YUM)
      • Count: 30 per bag (YUM)
      • Hook slot: yes (YUM)
      • Hook size: not published
      • Price tier: $$$

      Berkley PowerBait Power Worm 7 in, Scented Ribbon-Tail

      Scented Ribbon-Tail

      Verdict

      A scented 7 in ribbon-tail for Texas rigs, in a colour one forum poster swears by.

      Evidence: No independent test; owner reports. r/bassfishing thread: Power Worm in Tequila Sunrise, length not stated.

      Berkley says its “Ribbontail design swims naturally on the fall with twitches and short hops” and that fish hold PowerBait “18 times longer”; that figure is Berkley’s own. In the r/bassfishing thread, one poster writes “I’ve caught 90% of my bass on the berkeley power worm (tequila sunrise only)”, the colour we link; the poster gives no length. Another calls Power Worms “my favorite.” bassresource suggests “a 3/0 to 4/0 hook is ideal for most 7-8 inch worms.”

      Specs (linked: Tequila Sunrise, 7 in, 13 count)

        Pros

        • PowerBait scent in a ribbon-tail Berkley says swims on the fall
        • Tequila Sunrise, the colour one poster credits with 90% of their bass

        Cons

        • The “18 times longer” hold is Berkley’s claim, not an independent test
        • A bright colour; bassresource suggests dark worms for dark water

        Who should buy it

        Bass anglers who want a scented mid-size worm on a Texas rig.

        Check on Amazon

        • Length: 7 in (Amazon listing; Berkley offers 4 to 12 in)
        • Count: 13 (Amazon listing)
        • Tail: ribbon tail (Berkley)
        • Scent: PowerBait formula (Berkley)
        • Price tier: $

        Zoom Ol’ Monster 10.5 in, Magnum Curl-Tail Worm

        Magnum Curl-Tail Worm
        Zoom Ol' Monster Bait-Pack of 9 (Junebug, 10.5-Inch)

        Zoom Ol' Monster 10.5 in

        Magnum Curl-Tail Worm

        Bass anglers who want a 10 in-class worm on a Texas or Carolina rig.

        $5.59 from AmazonAs of Nov 18, 21:02 UTC

        Verdict

        A 10.5 in curl-tail for big bass on Texas and Carolina rigs.

        Evidence: No independent test; owner reports. r/bassfishing thread: Ol’ Monster, colour not stated.

        Zoom describes a “Slender body and massive curled tail”, salt-impregnated, for “a Texas rig, a Carolina rig or even a mag shakey head”, and says “Its considerable length, slender profile and curled tail are great for targeting large bass,” though it may tempt “bass of every size.” One r/bassfishing poster’s choice for “big 10″ worms” is “zoom ol monster/strike king rage anaconda.” Sold by Tackle Shack Outdoors on Amazon at the time of writing, below Zoom’s list price.

        Specs (linked: Junebug, 10.5 in, 9-pack)

          Pros

          • Long curled tail Zoom aims at large bass
          • Salt-impregnated plastic (Zoom)

          Cons

          • A 10.5 in worm, more than twice the length of the finesse picks
          • Third-party seller (Tackle Shack Outdoors)

          Who should buy it

          Bass anglers who want a 10 in-class worm on a Texas or Carolina rig.

          Check on Amazon

          • Length: 10.5 in (Zoom)
          • Count: 9 (Zoom)
          • Plastic: salt-impregnated (Zoom)
          • Hook size: not published
          • Price tier: $

          Roboworm Straight Tail Worm 4.5 in, Finesse Straight-Tail

          Finesse Straight-Tail

          Verdict

          A slim 4.5 in straight-tail for finesse fishing, sold by Amazon.com.

          Evidence: No independent test; owner reports. r/bassfishing thread: Roboworm straight tail, size and colour not stated.

          Roboworm makes it in “triple color pours” with a “salt release system”: “When a fish strikes these worms, a burst of salt is emitted, causing the fish to hold onto the bait longer.” In the r/bassfishing thread, one poster uses “roboworm straight tail for finesse”; another likes Roboworms “For Texas rigs and such.” bassresource advises “When fish are inactive, try using a smaller worm,” with a 1 or 1/0 hook for finesse worms. Neither poster names a colour.

          Specs (linked: Aaron’s Magic, 4.5 in, 10-pack)

            Pros

            • Slim straight tail a poster uses for finesse fishing
            • Three-colour pour (Roboworm)

            Cons

            • A small, subtle worm; bassresource keeps smaller worms for inactive fish
            • The salt-release claim is Roboworm’s own, not an independent test

            Who should buy it

            Anglers fishing pressured or inactive bass on finesse rigs.

            Check on Amazon

            • Length: 4.5 in (Roboworm)
            • Count: 10 per bag (Roboworm)
            • Salt: “salt release system” (Roboworm)
            • Hook size: not published
            • Price tier: $

            Z-Man Finesse TRD 2.75 in, Floating Ned Worm

            Floating Ned Worm
            Z-MAN TRD275-316PK8 Finesse TRD Lures, 2 3/4" Length, Green…

            Z-Man Finesse TRD 2.75 in

            Floating Ned Worm

            Bass anglers who fish a ned rig and want baits that last.

            $7.49 from AmazonAs of Nov 19, 00:10 UTC

            Verdict

            A 2.75 in floating ned worm in Z-Man’s stretchy ElaZtech plastic.

            Evidence: No independent test; owner reports. r/bassfishing thread: Z-Man ned baits, model not stated.

            Z-Man calls the TRD “the original 2.75″ Ned Rig stickworm” and describes its “floating, ElaZtech® material” and “10X Tough durability.” In the r/bassfishing brand thread, one poster uses Z-Man “mostly for their Ned stuff”; another says Z-Man’s bugs and ned baits “are durable as all can hell” and that he can “catch 10+ fish on a single bait.” Neither names the TRD or this colour. Sold by March Merchandise and shipped by Amazon at the time of writing, priced above Z-Man’s list.

            Specs (linked: Green Pumpkin Goby, 2.75 in, 8-pack, TRD275-316PK8)

              Pros

              • Floating ElaZtech plastic Z-Man rates “10X Tough”
              • A poster reports 10 or more fish on one Z-Man bait (his bugs and ned baits; he doesn’t name the TRD)

              Cons

              • Amazon price above Z-Man’s list when we checked
              • Needs a ned jighead, sold separately

              Who should buy it

              Bass anglers who fish a ned rig and want baits that last.

              Check on Amazon

              • Length: 2.75 in (Z-Man)
              • Count: 8 (Z-Man)
              • Material: ElaZtech, floating (Z-Man)
              • Jighead: not included
              • Price tier: $$

              Berkley Gulp! Nightcrawler 6 in, Scented Nightcrawler

              Scented Nightcrawler
              Berkley Gulp! Nightcrawler Natural, 6-Inch

              Berkley Gulp! Nightcrawler 6 in

              Scented Nightcrawler

              Walleye and bass anglers on spinner rigs or jigheads, and anyone replacing live nightcrawlers.

              $8.99 from AmazonAs of Nov 19, 00:10 UTC

              Verdict

              A scented 6 in nightcrawler copy for walleye and bass, and a stand-in for live crawlers.

              Evidence: No independent test; owner reports. r/FishingForBeginners thread: Gulp! nightcrawlers, size not stated.

              Berkley lists it as “Great on spinner rigs and weedless jigheads” and “Excellent for walleyes and bass,” with Gulp! “scent dispersion.” The r/FishingForBeginners poster wanted a fake worm for a bobber and hook; one reply says “If you’re doing hook and bobber, Gulp earthworm and nightcrawlers work really well,” without a size, and another suggests “Berkley Gulp Alive” for that setup. Two other replies warn that plain plastics need movement: “You’re gonna need to be moving the bait to give it action.”

              Related guide: Best Plastic Bait for Bass: Soft Plastics by Rig

              Specs (linked: Natural, 6 in, 10 count, GNC6-NAT)

                Pros

                • Gulp! scent, the kind of bait a reply suggests under a bobber
                • Made for spinner rigs and weedless jigheads (Berkley)

                Cons

                • Berkley publishes no weight or buoyancy
                • No reply names a size; the 6 in is our pick, not a poster’s

                Who should buy it

                Walleye and bass anglers on spinner rigs or jigheads, and anyone replacing live nightcrawlers.

                Check on Amazon

                • Length: 6 in (Berkley)
                • Count: 10 (Berkley)
                • Scent: Gulp! (Berkley)
                • Buoyancy: not published
                • Price tier: $$

                Berkley Gulp! Floating Pinched Crawler 2 in, Floating Pinched Crawler

                Floating Pinched Crawler
                Berkley Gulp! Floating Pinched Crawler Nightcrawler, 2-Inch

                Berkley Gulp! Floating Pinched Crawler 2 in

                Floating Pinched Crawler

                Trout and panfish anglers who want a scented worm in place of live bait.

                $5.62 from AmazonAs of Nov 19, 00:10 UTC

                Verdict

                A 2 in floating half-crawler for trout and panfish.

                Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: Berkley product page.

                Berkley calls it a “Lifelike imitation of a nightcrawler pinched in half” whose “Curved profile provides lifelike action when twitched or shaken,” sold in a resealable bag. The Amazon listing says this floating bait “is great for trout and panfish” and gives a “Smaller presentation when fish are less likely to bite a larger bait.” We found no independent test or forum report naming it.

                Specs (linked: Nightcrawler, original scent, 2 in, GHFPC2-NC)

                  Pros

                  • Small pinched-crawler shape the listing aims at trout and panfish
                  • Gulp! scent in a resealable bag (Berkley)

                  Cons

                  • Maker and listing claims only; no independent report found
                  • Berkley publishes no count per bag

                  Who should buy it

                  Trout and panfish anglers who want a scented worm in place of live bait.

                  Check on Amazon

                  • Length: 2 in (Berkley; also 1 in)
                  • Buoyancy: floating (Berkley)
                  • Count: not published
                  • Price tier: $

                  Worm Types, Rigs and Hooks

                  Stick, ribbon-tail, straight-tail and ned worms

                  A poster on r/FishingForBeginners sums up worms as “two basic style: stick and tailed,” fished “texas rigged, carolina rigged, and whacky.” bassresource says “Bulkier worms with twist tails, multiple tails, appendages, or similar attention-getting devices usually are best in water of low visibility and thick cover,” and to “Use thin worms with straight tails in vegetation.” For a baitfish profile instead of a worm, see our hard swimbaits guide, and our types of fishing lures guide for the wider picture.

                  Wacky, Texas and ned rigged soft plastic worms side by side
                  Illustration: wacky, Texas and ned rigs, three ways to fish a fake worm

                  Scented worms vs live bait

                  Plain plastics are worked, not soaked: one r/FishingForBeginners reply says “You don’t really use artificial worms as subs for real worms” under a bobber. Scented Berkley baits are the exception our sources name for a hook-and-bobber setup: one reply names Gulp! nightcrawlers, the kind we link at pick 7. Berkley pitches the non-floating Pinched Crawler, not the floating one we link, for use under a bobber. For live crawlers, see our guide to putting a worm on a hook.

                  Hook size and sinker weight

                  bassresource matches the hook to the worm: “a 3/0 to 4/0 hook is ideal for most 7-8 inch worms,” “A 2/0 hook is best for 5-6 inch worms, and 1 and 1/0 for finesse worms.” For sinkers it says “Use the lightest slip sinker you can”: “1/16 to 1/8 ounce” in water under 6 feet, “1/8 to 1/4 ounce sinker for 6 to 12 feet,” and heavier deeper. Our bass rigging guide shows the Texas, Carolina, wacky, ned and drop shot rigs step by step.

                  Frequently Asked Questions

                  Q. What is the best fake bait to use for fishing?

                  It depends on the fish. For bass, posters in our two threads name stick worms such as the Senko and Dinger and ribbon-tails such as the Power Worm; for a bobber and hook, two replies point to scented Gulp! baits.

                  Q. Do fake worms work for fishing?

                  Yes, if you move them. An r/FishingForBeginners reply says a plastic “doesn’t quite work the same” as a live worm under a bobber; scented baits like Gulp! are the closer swap.

                  Q. What are fake fishing worms called?

                  Soft plastics or plastic worms. bassresource lists “weenie worms, craw worms, lizards, curl tail, finesse, and ribbon-tail worms”; stick worms such as the Senko are another family.

                  Q. How do you hook a fake worm?

                  For a Texas rig, bassresource threads the hook “through the tip of the worm, and the point is turned back into the head of the worm to make it weedless.” For a wacky rig, Yamamoto hooks a Senko “through the middle.” Our worm hooking guide walks through both.

                  Q. How do you fish with fake worms?

                  bassresource’s Texas-rig method: cast past cover, “Let the worm fall to the bottom on a slack line,” lift the rod tip, let it fall, and set the hook on a tap.

                  The bottom line

                  Final Verdict

                  For bass on a wacky or weightless rig, start with the Yamamoto Senko 5 in (check price), or the YUM Dinger 5 in 30-pack (check price) if you want more worms per bag. For a Texas rig, the Berkley PowerBait Power Worm 7 in (check price) adds scent, and the Zoom Ol’ Monster 10.5 in (check price) goes bigger. For finesse fishing, the Roboworm Straight Tail Worm 4.5 in (check price) or the Z-Man Finesse TRD 2.75 in (check price) on a ned head. In place of live bait, the Berkley Gulp! Nightcrawler 6 in (check price) for walleye and bass, and the Berkley Gulp! Floating Pinched Crawler 2 in (check price) for trout and panfish.

                  Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

                  Outgearly Team
                  Outgearly Team

                  Written and reviewed by the Outgearly Team. See the About page for how we work.