The short answer
For wet hands, the Glacier Glove Ice Bay is fleece-lined neoprene, Field & Stream’s waterproof pick; for long days on the ice, the IceArmor by Clam Edge X Glove pairs mapped Thinsulate with a waterproof insert; for knots, the KastKing PolarBlast Mittens flip open on magnets.
Our verdict
Winter Fishing Glove Top Picks
Winter fishing gloves must stay warm and dry yet free your fingers for knots. As Field & Stream’s ice fishing writer puts it, “there is no one perfect pair, but several that can be used to match the weather conditions and the style of fishing of a given day.”
We compare ten gloves and mitts from seven brands: fleece-lined neoprene, insulated shell gloves, and flip-finger or fold-over mitts. No maker here publishes a temperature rating, so we compare insulation, waterproofing, material and finger design as each maker lists them. Our guide to gloves for fly fishing covers other models (no shared picks); for the rest of the kit, browse our fishing gear guides.
Glove finder
Find a winter fishing glove for your day
Pick how you fish and a price tier. The suggestion is our editorial starting point among the ten gloves below, drawn from the maker specs and reviews cited in each review, not a test result.
Tiers are relative to the gloves in this guide; live prices are in the comparison table below.
Compare the picks
Compare the 10 Winter Fishing Gloves
Each row names the size the link opens; switch sizes on Amazon. Figures are the makers’.
Glacier Ice BaySeamless Neoprene GloveIce holes, wet handsFull-finger neoprene$44.99
Evidence: Field & Stream links this Large listing; size worn not stated
Glacier Perfect CurvePre-Curved Neoprene GloveIce holes, wet handsPre-curved neoprene$43.00
Evidence: Field & Stream links the Large listing; we link the X-Large; size worn not stated
Clam Edge XMapped-Insulation GloveIce fishing, all-dayInsulated glove$49.99
Evidence: maker specs only, no independent test
Clam Extreme MittPrimaLoft Ice MittIce fishing, travelMitten$69.99
Evidence: maker specs only, no independent test
Striker AttackHipora-Insert GloveIce fishing, tip-upsInsulated glove$89.99
Evidence: Field & Stream links this Large listing; size worn not stated
Fish Monkey SherpaFlip-Finger Sherpa GloveIce jigging, knotsFlip finger and thumb$69.95
Evidence: maker specs only, no independent test
Simms Guide InsulatedLeather Gauntlet GloveBoat days, rowingLeather gauntlet$149.95 Prime
Evidence: maker specs only, no independent test
Simms Foldover MittFleece Fold-Over MittOpen water, riversFold-over mitt$40.00 Prime
Evidence: maker specs only, no independent test
KastKing PolarBlastMagnetic Flip-Top MittenIce jigging, knotsMagnetic flip-top mitten$33.99 Prime
Evidence: maker specs only, no independent test
Bassdash WinteFlexHand-Warmer-Pocket MittenIce jigging, budgetMagnetic flip-top mitten$34.98
Evidence: maker specs only, no independent test
How We Chose Gloves for Ice and Cold Water
How this guide was built
built from manufacturer documentation, published third-party reviews and owner reports; we have not tested these products ourselves.
What every pick had to show
- A cold-weather or ice-fishing tie from the maker or a named reviewer.
- Insulation and waterproofing as the maker words them.
- A finger plan: grip palm, flip-top or fold-over.
- The exact Amazon listing, checked for size, stock and seller.
Sources behind each pick and what winter anglers on r/flyfishing suggest
Sources behind each pick
Field & Stream and Outdoor Life do not sell gloves. Field & Stream reviews three of our picks (both Glacier Gloves and the Striker Attack) and links Large listings (we link the Perfect Curve in X-Large), without saying which size the writer wore. The other seven rest on maker specs, quoted as claims.
What winter anglers on r/flyfishing suggest
The r/flyfishing winter gloves thread starts with a poster whose wool half-finger gloves stay wet when stripping line. Six replies suggest nitrile gloves, three of them saying underneath; one poster disagrees, because nitrile ends up “trapping water and/or tearing,” and instead brings three pairs of cheap wool or merino gloves and swaps them as they get wet.
Winter Fishing Gloves: Detailed Reviews
Glacier Glove Ice Bay, Seamless Neoprene Glove
Ice anglers who reach into holes or land fish by hand and want a glove that stays waterproof.
$44.99 from AmazonAs of Nov 18, 20:58 UTCVerdict
Fleece-lined neoprene with a seamless palm, for anglers whose hands go into the water.
Evidence: Independently reviewed, same series. Field & Stream: Ice Bay, size not stated.
Glacier Glove calls the 2 mm fleece-lined neoprene “100% waterproof” and “blind stitched & glued.” Field & Stream named it its waterproof pick: “These gloves, however, are made from neoprene with sealed seams to give you a waterproof glove that insulates well against the cold.” The writer warns that “neoprene doesn’t breathe, so your hands can sweat.” Outdoor Life’s winter pick is the Ice Bay too: “These gloves allow anglers to reach into the cold water without losing feeling,” though its writer “couldn’t tie knots with them.” Sold by Glacier Outdoor’s own Amazon storefront at the time of writing.
Specs (linked: Ice Bay, Large)
Pros
- Full neoprene, palm included, with sealed seams, per Field & Stream
- Two independent reviews name it for cold-water fishing
Cons
- Neoprene does not breathe, so hands can sweat, per Field & Stream
- Too thick to tie knots, per Outdoor Life; not touchscreen compatible, per Field & Stream
Who should buy it
Ice anglers who reach into holes or land fish by hand and want a glove that stays waterproof.
- Material: 2 mm Techline neoprene, fleece lining (Glacier Glove)
- Palm: seamless, sharkskin texture (Glacier Glove)
- Price tier: $$ (live Amazon price in the table above)
Glacier Glove Perfect Curve, Pre-Curved Neoprene Glove
Ice anglers who grip a rod all day and want neoprene shaped to the hand.
$43.00 from AmazonAs of Nov 18, 20:58 UTCVerdict
The Ice Bay’s neoprene with fingers shaped to a grip.
Evidence: Independently reviewed, same series. Field & Stream: Perfect Curve, size not stated.
Glacier Glove lists the same 2 mm fleece-lined neoprene with “Pre-curved fingers [that] mimic the natural shape of your hand.” Field & Stream, its overall pick: “The company molds the curve of your fingers at mid-grip right into the glove, giving them a natural shape.” Its caveat: “they’re a little harder to get on and off.” Grip matters on a short jigging rod; see our ice fishing rods guide. Sold by Gritr on Amazon at the time of writing, below Glacier’s list price.
Against the Ice Bay: same neoprene, plus pre-curved fingers and a strap, but harder to pull off.
Specs (linked: Perfect Curve, X-Large)
Pros
- Pre-curved fingers hold a rod or fish with less bunching, per Field & Stream
- Neoprene listed as fully waterproof, per Glacier Glove
Cons
- Harder to get on and off, per Field & Stream
- Not touchscreen compatible, per Field & Stream
Who should buy it
Ice anglers who grip a rod all day and want neoprene shaped to the hand.
- Material: 2 mm fleece-lined Techline neoprene (Glacier Glove)
- Fingers: pre-curved (Glacier Glove)
- Price tier: $$ (live Amazon price in the table above)
IceArmor by Clam Edge X Glove, Mapped-Insulation Glove
Ice anglers who want a mid-priced insulated glove from an ice-fishing brand.
$49.99 from AmazonAs of Nov 18, 20:58 UTCVerdict
An ice-fishing glove from Clam with more insulation on the back than the palm and a waterproof insert.
Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: Clam Outdoors.
Clam lists a DWR “300D Oxford Shell,” a “Dri-Vent Waterproof/Breathable Insert,” “Mapped 3M™ Thinsulate™ Insulation” (“150 g in the palm, 200g on the back of the hand”), a polyurethane palm and a neoprene cuff. We found no independent review. Sold by Clam Outdoors’ own Amazon storefront at the time of writing.
Specs (linked: Edge X, Large)
Pros
- Thinner insulation in the palm for grip, thicker on the back, per Clam
Cons
- Full fingers: gloves off for knots
- No independent review found
Who should buy it
Ice anglers who want a mid-priced insulated glove from an ice-fishing brand.
- Insulation: 3M Thinsulate, 200 g back, 150 g palm (Clam)
- Waterproofing: Dri-Vent insert; DWR shell (Clam)
- Price tier: $$ (live Amazon price in the table above)
IceArmor by Clam Extreme Mitt, PrimaLoft Ice Mitt
Ice anglers who sit out in the open and want a mitten over a liner between bites.
$69.99 from AmazonAs of Nov 18, 20:58 UTCVerdict
A full mitten for long, cold sits and the walk out; take it off to fish.
Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: Clam Outdoors.
Clam lists “Waterproof / Breathable Construction,” “Mapped PrimaLoft® Insulation” (weight not published), a “ThermalSnare™ Fleece Lining” and a “Reflective Safety Panel” for “low-light or early-morning ice fishing.” Sold by Clam Outdoors’ storefront at the time of writing.
Specs (linked: Extreme Mitt, Large)
Pros
- Mitten with fleece lining and PrimaLoft, per Clam
- Reflective panel for early mornings on the ice, per Clam
Cons
- No finger access: off for every knot
- Insulation weight not published; no independent review found
Who should buy it
Ice anglers who sit out in the open and want a mitten over a liner between bites.
- Insulation: mapped PrimaLoft, weight not published (Clam)
- Shell: 600D polyester; leather palm reinforcements (Clam)
- Price tier: $$ (live Amazon price in the table above)
Striker Attack Glove, Hipora-Insert Glove
Ice anglers running tip-ups who pull gloves on and off often.
$89.99 from AmazonAs of Nov 18, 20:58 UTCVerdict
A Thinsulate glove with a wide strap and neoprene cuff.
Evidence: Independently reviewed, same series. Field & Stream: Attack, size not stated.
Striker lists “150g 3M Thinsulate® Insulation,” a “Hipora® Waterproof/Breathable” insert, a suede palm and a neoprene cuff. Field & Stream: “They’re made with 150 grams of Thinsulate insulation, so they’re warm but not too bulky.” Its caveat: “they feel a little cumbersome to me and my fat fingers.” Sold by Frank’s Great Outdoors on Amazon at the time of writing, at Striker’s list price.
Against the Edge X: Clam lists more insulation on the back; the Attack has an independent review, at a higher tier.
Specs (linked: Attack, Black, Large)
Pros
- Warm without bulk, per Field & Stream
- Wide strap makes it quick on and off, per Field & Stream
Cons
- Cumbersome on larger hands, per Field & Stream
- Premium tier for a full-finger glove
- Insulation: 150 g 3M Thinsulate (Striker)
- Waterproofing: Hipora insert (Striker)
- Price tier: $$$ (live Amazon price in the table above)
Fish Monkey Stealth Sherpa Dry-Tec, Flip-Finger Sherpa Glove
Ice anglers who jig and retie often and want one glove instead of a mitt and liner.
$69.95 from AmazonAs of Nov 18, 20:58 UTCVerdict
A heavy insulated glove whose index finger and thumb fold back, per owners on Fish Monkey’s page.
Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: Fish Monkey.
Fish Monkey’s page for this model (FM52) lists a “Dry-Tec™ 100% waterproof and windproof membrane,” 200 g back and 100 g palm insulation and a Sherpa fleece lining, but no flip finger. An owner: “I like how you fold back your index finger and be able to touch and feel the trigger.” Sold by The Kingfisher on Amazon at the time of writing, at Fish Monkey’s list price.
Specs (linked: Stealth Sherpa Dry-Tec, Gray/Black, Large)
Pros
- Fold-back index finger and thumb, per two owners on Fish Monkey’s page
- Waterproof membrane in a heavily insulated glove, per Fish Monkey
Cons
- Neither Fish Monkey’s spec list nor Amazon’s names the flip finger
- No independent review found
Who should buy it
Ice anglers who jig and retie often and want one glove instead of a mitt and liner.
- Insulation: 200 g back, 100 g palm; 380 g Sherpa lining (Fish Monkey)
- Waterproofing: Dry-Tec membrane, DWR (Fish Monkey)
- Price tier: $$ (live Amazon price in the table above)
Simms Guide Insulated Glove, Leather Gauntlet Glove
Boat anglers and guides who grip oars and throttles through winter and want leather durability.
$149.95 from AmazonAs of Nov 18, 20:58 UTCVerdict
A leather gauntlet glove for running and rowing boats in the cold; not sold as waterproof.
Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: Simms.
Simms lists “PrimaLoft® Gold (133g),” a “Full leather palm and back-of-hand” and an adjustable nylon gauntlet. Its tagline: “PrimaLoft® Gold warmth and full-leather durability keep cold, wet boat days workable.” Simms says “dry” but does not list a waterproof membrane. Sold by Amazon.com at the time of writing.
Specs (linked: Guide Insulated Glove, Black, Large)
Pros
- Full leather palm and back of hand, per Simms
- Adjustable gauntlet “to seal in warmth,” per Simms
Cons
- Top price tier in this guide
- Waterproofing not stated by Simms; no independent review found
Who should buy it
Boat anglers and guides who grip oars and throttles through winter and want leather durability.
- Insulation: 133 g PrimaLoft Gold (Simms)
- Shell: coated nylon and goat leather (Simms)
- Price tier: $$$ (live Amazon price in the table above)
Simms Freestone Foldover Mitt, Fleece Fold-Over Mitt
Anglers casting from boats or banks on cold, dry days who need fingertips free.
$40.00 from AmazonAs of Nov 18, 20:58 UTCVerdict
A half-finger fleece glove with a stowable mitt, for cold open water rather than wet ice holes.
Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: Simms.
Simms says it “Keeps hands warm yet frees fingers fast for rigging in cold, wet conditions,” with a “Stowable overmitt [that] prevents line snag” and a 250 g/m2 fleece shell with a DWR finish. A Trout and Steelhead guide, writing about Orvis and Simms flip mitts generally: “Yes, they are not waterproof.” Sold by Amazon.com at the time of writing.
Against the PolarBlast and WinteFlex: one DWR fleece layer, no lining listed, higher tier.
Specs (linked: Freestone Foldover Mitt, Black, Large)
Pros
- Mitt folds over bare fingertips between casts, per Simms
- TPU palm overlays for rod grip, per Simms
Cons
- Water-resistant finish only, not waterproof
- No independent review found
Who should buy it
Anglers casting from boats or banks on cold, dry days who need fingertips free.
- Fabric: 250 g/m2 polyester-spandex fleece, DWR (Simms)
- Palm: TPU overlays (Simms)
- Price tier: $$ (live Amazon price in the table above)
KastKing PolarBlast Mittens, Magnetic Flip-Top Mitten
Budget ice anglers who jig and want bare fingertips without taking a mitten off.
$33.99 from AmazonAs of Nov 18, 20:58 UTCVerdict
A budget four-layer flip-top mitten whose finger and thumb flaps hold back with magnets.
Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: KastKing.
KastKing lists “Waterproof and windproof 4 layer construction” with “40 grams of 3M Thinsultate” and says “Built-in magnets hold the thumb and finger flaps out of the way.” A customer review hosted on KastKing’s site: “The magnet kept the mitten flap secured throughout the day.” For the line those freed fingers will tie, see our braided ice fishing line guide. Sold by KastKing’s own Amazon storefront at the time of writing.
Specs (linked: PolarBlast, Blackout, Large)
Pros
- Magnets hold both flaps open for knots and phones, per KastKing
- Four layers, including a membrane and Thinsulate, per KastKing
Cons
- Less Thinsulate (40 g) than the Thinsulate gloves here, per each maker
- Evidence is maker copy and one maker-hosted review
Who should buy it
Budget ice anglers who jig and want bare fingertips without taking a mitten off.
- Insulation: 40 g 3M Thinsulate (KastKing)
- Shell: stretch poly fleece; waterproof per KastKing’s bullets, water-resistant per its Amazon title
- Price tier: $ (live Amazon price in the table above)
Bassdash WinteFlex Mittens, Hand-Warmer-Pocket Mitten
Budget anglers on dry, cold days who like to slip a heat pack in.
$34.98 from AmazonAs of Nov 18, 20:58 UTCVerdict
A budget flip-top mitten with a pocket for a heat pack; water-resistant, not waterproof.
Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: Bassdash.
Bassdash lists a “water-resistant Poly-Spandex shell,” 160 gsm fleece insulation, a “magnetic flip top and thumb hood” and “One inner pocket for a hand warmer heat pack.” Sold by Bassdash’s own Amazon storefront at the time of writing.
Against the PolarBlast: no membrane or Thinsulate listed, plus a heat-pack pocket.
Specs (linked: WinteFlex, Black, Large)
Pros
- Pocket for a hand-warmer pack, per Bassdash
- Silicone grip on a partial synthetic leather palm, per Bassdash
Cons
- Water-resistant only, per Bassdash
- No independent review found
- Insulation: 160 gsm fleece, 220 gsm lining (Bassdash)
- Shell: water-resistant poly-spandex (Bassdash)
- Price tier: $ (live Amazon price in the table above)
Choosing Gloves for Cold-Weather Fishing
Neoprene or an insulated shell glove
Neoprene (picks 1-2) keeps hands dry when they go into the water but, per Field & Stream, “doesn’t breathe.” Shell gloves with Thinsulate or PrimaLoft (picks 3, 5, 6 and 7) carry a waterproof/breathable insert, per Clam, Striker and Fish Monkey; Simms lists no membrane on its leather glove.
Fingerless, flip-top and fold-over mitts
A flip-top mitten (picks 9-10), a fold-over mitten on a half-finger glove (pick 8) or a flip-back finger (pick 6) frees fingertips without baring the hand. Trout and Steelhead’s guide fishes fingerless and flips the mitt over “when i’m walking from spot to spot.”
Waterproof fishing gloves: membrane, neoprene or DWR
Neoprene gloves are called waterproof outright (Glacier). Shell gloves carry a waterproof/breathable insert (Clam, Striker, Fish Monkey). Simms’ DWR fleece and Bassdash’s shell are sold as water-resistant. Field & Stream’s caution: a waterproof lining “is really only as good as the seal.”
Sizing, liners and women’s fit
Every pick comes in men’s or unisex sizes; on Amazon the smallest size is XS for the Ice Bay, Simms Guide and WinteFlex; Small for the Perfect Curve, Edge X and PolarBlast; Medium for the Striker, Fish Monkey and Foldover. Field & Stream suggests a liner under a heavier outer glove. For warm feet, see our women’s ice fishing boots.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q. What are the best gloves for fishing in the winter?
Field & Stream picked the neoprene Glacier Glove Perfect Curve overall and the Ice Bay for waterproofing; for knots, a flip-top mitten or fold-back-finger glove keeps fingers covered between them.
Q. What to wear to go fishing in winter?
Our ice fishing suits guide covers the outer layer and our women’s ice fishing boots the feet.
Q. What are the best gloves for shooting in cold weather?
Of our picks, a Fish Monkey owner can “touch and feel the trigger” with its finger folded back.
Q. What are the best gloves for keeping warm in winter?
Field & Stream’s answer: “The warmest gloves you will find will actually be two pairs: an outer glove and a liner glove.”
The bottom line
Final Verdict
For wet hands, choose the Glacier Glove Ice Bay (check price), or the Glacier Glove Perfect Curve (check price) for pre-curved fingers. On the ice, the IceArmor by Clam Edge X Glove (check price) maps Thinsulate, the Striker Attack Glove (check price) adds an independent review, and the Fish Monkey Stealth Sherpa Dry-Tec (check price) folds a finger back for knots. The IceArmor by Clam Extreme Mitt (check price) suits long sits; the Simms Guide Insulated Glove (check price) suits boat days. For free fingertips, pick the Simms Freestone Foldover Mitt (check price) on dry open water, or the budget KastKing PolarBlast Mittens (check price) and Bassdash WinteFlex Mittens (check price).
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
