8 Best Catfish Baits to Use: Punch, Dip, Dough and Liver Cure

10 min read

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Read our affiliate disclosure.

The short answer

For a punch bait on a treble hook, Danny King Catfish Punch Bait; for a channel-cat dip bait, Triple S Catfish Bait; for a preformed chicken-liver bait, Berkley PowerBait Catfish Bait Chunks.

Our verdict

Catfish Baits to Use: Top Picks

Catfish bait is either natural (cut shad, chicken liver, nightcrawlers) or prepared: punch, dip, dough and scented baits in a tub or jar. This page covers the half you can order: seven prepared baits and one chicken-liver cure from seven makers, each linked at the exact flavor and size. Trout anglers: see our PowerBait roundup for trout. For rods and reels, browse our fishing gear guides.

Related guide: Best Fake Bait for Catfish: Artificial Baits and Lures

Catfish bait finder

Find a catfish bait for where you fish

Pick where you fish and a price tier per container. The suggestion is our editorial starting point among the eight baits below, drawn from the makers' pages and the sources cited in each review, not a test result.

Where will you fish?
Price tier

Tiers are relative to the baits in this guide; live prices are in the comparison table below.

Compare the picks

Compare the 8 Catfish Baits

“Not stated”: neither maker nor listing names it.

Mr. Whiskers Catfish Punch Bait - Blood - 1 QuartMr. Whiskers Catfish Punch BaitBlood Punch Bait, QuartChannel cats, blue cats, riversPunch bait$14.99 Prime
Linked sizeBlood, 32 oz
Species namedMaker: channel and blue cats
Hook namedMaker: treble

Evidence: maker specs only, no independent test

Danny King Catfish Punch Bait | 12oz Tub | Best Catfish…Danny King Catfish Punch BaitSmall-Tub Punch BaitCurrent, treble rigsPunch bait$14.99
Linked sizeBlood, 12 oz
Species namedMaker: catfish
Hook namedAcademy: size 4 treble

Evidence: Field & Stream, punch bait line; flavor and tub not stated

45oz Triple S Catfish Bait Tub - Blooded Formula - Formerly…Triple S Catfish BaitBlooded Dip BaitChannel catsDip bait$19.99
Linked sizeBlooded, 45 oz
Species namedName: channel catfish

Evidence: Field & Stream, original or blooded; tub size not stated

Berkley PowerBait Catfish Bait Chunks , Chicken Liver 6…Berkley PowerBait Catfish Bait ChunksPreformed Liver ChunksChicken liver, all-roundPreformed chunks$7.99 Prime
Linked sizeChicken Liver, 6 oz
Species namedMaker: catfish

Evidence: Field & Stream, six scents incl. chicken liver; jar size not stated

Berkley Gulp! Catfish Dough Bloody Bloody, 5-OunceBerkley Gulp! Catfish DoughGulp! Dough NuggetsPonds, lakesDough nuggets$8.99 Prime
Linked sizeBloody Bloody, 5 oz
Species namedMaker: catfish
Hook namedMaker: treble

Evidence: owner reports, no independent test

Fishbites Freshwater Catfish Bait, Odor-Free, Shad Blood…Fishbites Freshwater Catfish BaitOdor-Free Shad BaitRivers, clean handsScented bait$7.67
Linked sizeShad, Blood
Species namedMaker: catfish

Evidence: maker specs only, no independent test

Pro-Cure Catfish Magic Chicken Liver Cure, 12 Ounce | Top…Pro-Cure Catfish Magic Chicken Liver CureChicken Liver CureChicken liver, stained waterLiver cure$15.76
Linked size12 oz
Species namedMaker: catfish

Evidence: maker specs only, no independent test

CJ's Catfish Shad Punch Bait, 1/2 GallonCJ's Catfish Shad Punch BaitHalf-Gallon Shad PunchCold water, bulkPunch bait$25.99
Linked sizeShad, 1/2 gallon
Species namedListing: catfish
Hook namedListing: treble

Evidence: Catfish Edge, CJ's punch bait line; flavor and size not stated

Prices as of Nov 18, 21:21 UTC

How We Chose These Catfish Baits

How this guide was built

built from manufacturer documentation, published third-party guides and owner reports; we have not tested these products ourselves.

What each bait had to show

  • Catfish on the label or the maker’s page. Pro-Cure lists its cure as working for catfish.
  • The exact flavor and size, on a single Amazon listing with no size options.
  • In stock and new on Amazon on the day of writing.
  • A distinct job: the three punch baits differ by size and seller.
Sources and their limits

Sources and their limits

Specs come from the makers and Amazon listings; retailer wording is labelled. Field & Stream names Danny King, Triple S and the PowerBait chunks; Catfish Edge names CJ’s; Iowa Sportsman names Sonny’s, the bait Triple S replaced. None names the size we link or describes a side-by-side test. Angler reports come from r/Fishing posters.

Catfish Baits: Detailed Reviews

Picks: Mr. Whiskers, Danny King, Triple S, PowerBait Chunks, Gulp! Dough, Fishbites, Pro-Cure, CJ’s.

Mr. Whiskers Catfish Punch Bait, Blood Punch Bait, Quart

Blood Punch Bait, Quart
Mr. Whiskers Catfish Punch Bait - Blood - 1 Quart

Mr. Whiskers Catfish Punch Bait

Blood 1 Quart

Cooler-water anglers after channel cats or blues who want a quart of punch bait.

$14.99 from AmazonAs of Nov 18, 21:21 UTC

Verdict

A quart of blood punch bait its maker pitches at channel cats and blues.

Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: Whisker Seeker Tackle (maker).

Whisker Seeker Tackle calls it a “thick, sticky catfish stink bait” built to “hold up in current, and consistently catch channel catfish and blues in lakes, rivers, and ponds.” The maker’s rule, from its own field reports: “Below 70°F: Try Blood first”; “Above 70°F: Start with Cheese.” It publishes no data behind it.

Mr. Whiskers, Danny King or CJ’s? Mr. Whiskers: a quart sold by Amazon.com. Danny King: a 12 oz tub with an independent write-up. CJ’s: a third-party half gallon.

Specs (linked: Blood, 1 quart)

    Pros

    • Blood formula the maker suggests below 70°F
    • Sold and shipped by Amazon.com at the time of writing

    Cons

    • No independent review among the sources we read
    • The maker suggests adding tissue or fiber if heat softens it

    Who should buy it

    Cooler-water anglers after channel cats or blues who want a quart of punch bait.

    Check on Amazon

    • Form: punch bait (maker)
    • Size: 32 oz (maker)
    • Hook: punch-bait treble (maker)
    • Price tier: $$ (live price above)

    Danny King Catfish Punch Bait, Small-Tub Punch Bait

    Small-Tub Punch Bait
    Danny King Catfish Punch Bait | 12oz Tub | Best Catfish…

    Danny King Catfish Punch Bait

    Blood 12 oz

    River anglers who want punch bait on a plain treble hook.

    $14.99 from AmazonAs of Nov 18, 21:21 UTC

    Verdict

    The punch bait Field & Stream names for treble hooks, in a 12 oz tub.

    Evidence: Independently reviewed, same series. Field & Stream: Catfish Punch Bait, flavor and tub not stated.

    Field & Stream lists it as “Best for Treble Hooks”: “This doughy, fibrous bait is sticky and holds tight to a treble hook, even in current, while still providing a followable scent trail.” Danny King sells the 12 oz tub in three flavors; Academy, a retailer, pairs it with “a size 4 treble hook.”

    Specs (linked: Blood, 12 oz tub)

      Pros

      • Field & Stream’s pick for treble hooks, holding “even in current”
      • Small tub for trying punch bait first

      Cons

      • Amazon price was above Danny King’s own list price at our check
      • Field & Stream names no flavor or tub size

      Who should buy it

      River anglers who want punch bait on a plain treble hook.

      Check on Amazon

      • Form: punch bait (maker)
      • Size: 12 oz (maker)
      • Hook: size 4 treble (Academy, retailer)
      • Price tier: $$ (live price above)

      Triple S Catfish Bait, Blooded Dip Bait

      Blooded Dip Bait
      45oz Triple S Catfish Bait Tub - Blooded Formula - Formerly…

      Triple S Catfish Bait

      Blooded Formula 45 oz

      Channel-cat anglers who already fish dip tubes or sponges.

      $19.99 from AmazonAs of Nov 18, 21:21 UTC

      Verdict

      The Sonny’s successor Field & Stream names for channel catfish.

      Evidence: Independently reviewed, same series. Field & Stream: Triple S Channel Cat Bait, tub size not stated.

      Retailers sell it as “Triple S Channel Catfish Bait,” formerly Sonny’s. Field & Stream: “As the best bait for channel catfish, this dip bait has a proven record for attracting the biggest channel cats that swim,” sold in “original formula or blooded.” Dip bait needs “a small tube, worm, or sponge,” per Catfish Edge.

      Specs (linked: Blooded Formula, 45 oz tub)

        Pros

        • Field & Stream’s pick for channel catfish, blooded or original
        • Large tub from Zeiner’s Angler Supply, a catfish-tackle retailer

        Cons

        • Needs dip tubes, worms or sponges to hold on the hook
        • No maker site found; details from retailers

        Who should buy it

        Channel-cat anglers who already fish dip tubes or sponges.

        Check on Amazon

        • Form: dip bait (retailers)
        • Size: 45 oz (Amazon listing)
        • Species: channel catfish (product name)
        • Price tier: $$ (live price above)

        Berkley PowerBait Catfish Bait Chunks, Preformed Liver Chunks

        Preformed Liver Chunks

        Verdict

        Chicken-liver scent without the liver, in Field & Stream’s overall pick.

        Evidence: Independently reviewed, same series. Field & Stream: PowerBait Catfish Bait Chunks, all scents; jar size not stated.

        Berkley sells the chunks “Preformed for quick and easy rigging” in six scents. Field & Stream lists them, chicken liver included, and calls the line “our pick for the best catfish bait overall.” It covers the line, not one jar.

        PowerBait Chunks or Gulp! Dough? Both are preformed Berkley baits. The chunks carry chicken-liver scent and an independent pick; the Gulp! dough is a blood scent with poster reports only.

        Specs (linked: Chicken Liver, 6 oz jar)

          Pros

          • Chicken-liver scent with no cutting or cleanup
          • Field & Stream’s overall pick for the line

          Cons

          • Berkley’s page names no hook type or size
          • Small jar beside the punch-bait tubs

          Who should buy it

          Chicken-liver fans who want a preformed bait in a jar.

          Check on Amazon

          • Form: preformed chunks (maker)
          • Size: 6 oz (Amazon listing)
          • Price tier: $ (live price above)

          Berkley Gulp! Catfish Dough, Gulp! Dough Nuggets

          Gulp! Dough Nuggets
          Berkley Gulp! Catfish Dough Bloody Bloody, 5-Ounce

          Berkley Gulp! Catfish Dough

          Bloody Bloody 5 oz

          Pond and lake anglers who want a clean, preformed blood bait.

          $8.99 from AmazonAs of Nov 18, 21:21 UTC

          Verdict

          Preformed blood-scent dough nuggets that posters keep for still water.

          Evidence: No independent test; owner reports. r/Fishing: Gulp! catfish dough, scent not stated.

          Berkley lists the 5 oz jar in “Bloody Blood” (Amazon’s “Bloody Bloody”), “Preformed into optimal nuggets making it easy to rig on treble or other catfish style hooks.” In an r/Fishing thread, one poster writes: “It works. I’ve caught cats on them,” but finds it “very hard to get the dough to stay on the hook.” Another finds them “not bad for still waters (ponds/lakes/reservoirs)” but not for current. Neither names a scent.

          Specs (linked: Bloody Bloody, 5 oz jar)

            Pros

            • Preformed nuggets Berkley rigs on treble or catfish hooks
            • Sold by Amazon.com at Berkley’s list price at our check

            Cons

            • Posters report it falling off the hook
            • No independent review among the sources we read

            Who should buy it

            Pond and lake anglers who want a clean, preformed blood bait.

            Check on Amazon

            • Form: dough nuggets (maker)
            • Size: 5 oz (maker)
            • Hook: treble or catfish hooks (maker)
            • Price tier: $ (live price above)

            Fishbites Freshwater Catfish Bait, Odor-Free Shad Bait

            Odor-Free Shad Bait
            Fishbites Freshwater Catfish Bait, Odor-Free, Shad Blood…

            Fishbites Freshwater Catfish Bait

            Shad Blood

            Anglers who want a clean, shelf-stable bait in the tackle bag.

            $7.67 from AmazonAs of Nov 18, 21:21 UTC

            Verdict

            Catfish bait without smelly hands, per its maker.

            Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: Fishbites (maker).

            Fishbites calls its catfish baits “Stink-Free” and says they “require no refrigeration and retain their scent and durability for at least a year when properly stored.” Its blog claims a scent trail “in moving water.”

            Specs (linked: Shad, Blood color)

              Pros

              • Odor-free to people, per Fishbites and the listing; no refrigeration
              • Maker says the scent trail holds in moving water

              Cons

              • Maker claims only; no independent review among the sources we read
              • Pack size not published

              Who should buy it

              Anglers who want a clean, shelf-stable bait in the tackle bag.

              Check on Amazon

              • Form: scented bait (Amazon listing)
              • Storage: no refrigeration (maker)
              • Pack size: not published
              • Price tier: $ (live price above)

              Pro-Cure Catfish Magic Chicken Liver Cure, Chicken Liver Cure

              Chicken Liver Cure

              Verdict

              Not a bait: a cure for anglers who fish chicken liver.

              Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: Pro-Cure (maker).

              Pro-Cure says it gives “your baits the perfect color and consistency with added shelf life” and calls its scents “UV-ENHANCED — VISIBLE IN STAINED WATER.” An r/Fishing poster names the usual liver problem: “it comes off the hook easily”; Pro-Cure’s page does not promise to fix it.

              Specs (linked: 12 oz)

                Pros

                • Adds color and shelf life to your own chicken liver, per Pro-Cure
                • UV-enhanced for stained water, per the maker

                Cons

                • You still buy the chicken liver
                • Sold by Pro-Cure Inc itself; maker claims only

                Who should buy it

                Chicken-liver anglers fishing stained water.

                Check on Amazon

                • Form: liver cure (maker)
                • Size: 12 oz (maker)
                • Price tier: $$ (live price above)

                CJ’s Catfish Shad Punch Bait, Half-Gallon Shad Punch

                Half-Gallon Shad Punch

                Verdict

                A half gallon of shad punch bait from a maker Catfish Edge vouches for.

                Evidence: Independently reviewed, same series. Catfish Edge: CJ’s Catfish Punch Bait, flavor and size not stated.

                Catfish Edge lists “CJ’s Catfish Punch Bait (every flavor I’ve tried has worked)” for channel cats, naming no flavor. Zeiner’s, a retailer, pitches the shad flavor to anglers “Having trouble finding shad entrails or sides” and suggests it “in the cold weather just like you do shad.” The listing says to “press the bait onto your treble hook.”

                Specs (linked: Shad, 1/2 gallon)

                  Pros

                  • Shad flavor in place of shad entrails
                  • Catfish Edge says every CJ’s flavor it tried has worked

                  Cons

                  • Sold by BiznessMan4U on Amazon at the time of writing, above Zeiner’s retail price
                  • Large container to start with

                  Who should buy it

                  Punch-bait regulars who want shad flavor in bulk.

                  Check on Amazon

                  • Form: punch bait (Amazon listing)
                  • Size: 1/2 gallon (Amazon listing)
                  • Price tier: $$$ (live price above)

                  Prepared Bait or Natural Bait?

                  Catfish Edge favors dip and punch baits for numbers of channel catfish, but writes: “Natural baits are going to be a better option if your goal is to catch larger channel catfish.” Dieter Melhorn prefers meat, led by gizzard shad.

                  Treble hook with dough bait beside a circle hook with cut bait
                  Illustration: a prepared dough bait beside a cut natural bait

                  Stink bait, punch bait and dip bait

                  Mossy Oak: dip baits “are liquid, whereas punch bait is solid.” Punch bait goes on a bare treble; dip bait needs a tube, worm or sponge.

                  Cut bait, chicken liver and hooks

                  In the ranking r/Fishing thread, posters favor cut bait “of the species they feed on in the same water,” and one adds that a “2/0 circle hook works best with small baits to catch numbers of fish.” See our guides to rigging a fishing rod, putting a worm on a hook and freshwater rods.

                  Rivers and ponds

                  For current: Danny King (Field & Stream) or Fishbites (maker claim). Posters keep Gulp! dough for ponds and lakes. For trout doughs, see our stocked-trout bait guide.

                  Frequently Asked Questions

                  Q. What’s the best catfish bait to use?

                  It depends on the goal: prepared baits for numbers of channel cats, natural bait for bigger fish (Catfish Edge). Of our eight, Field & Stream picks the PowerBait chunks overall, Triple S for channel cats and Danny King for treble hooks.

                  Q. What is Secret 7 catfish bait?

                  A dip bait from Team Catfish, which says it “catches channel cats and blue cats alike.” The Amazon offer we found was a third-party three-pack priced well above Team Catfish’s own, so it is not a pick.

                  Q. What smell attracts catfish the most?

                  None of our sources ranks smells. Mr. Whiskers’ maker suggests blood below 70°F and cheese above, from its own reports.

                  Q. Can you make your own catfish bait?

                  Yes. Catfish Edge: “You can always make your own catfish bait also but I’ve always preferred to just buy something that I know works.” If punch bait softens in heat, Mr. Whiskers’ maker suggests adding “shredded tissue or fiber.”

                  The bottom line

                  Final Verdict

                  Punch bait: the Danny King Catfish Punch Bait (check price), the quart Mr. Whiskers Catfish Punch Bait (check price) or bulk CJ’s Catfish Shad Punch Bait (check price). Dip bait for channel cats: the Triple S Catfish Bait (check price). For liver scent in a jar, the Berkley PowerBait Catfish Bait Chunks (check price); for liver you buy yourself, the Pro-Cure Catfish Magic Chicken Liver Cure (check price). For still water, the Berkley Gulp! Catfish Dough (check price); for clean hands, the Fishbites Freshwater Catfish Bait (check price).

                  Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

                  Outgearly Team
                  Outgearly Team

                  Written and reviewed by the Outgearly Team. See the About page for how we work.