4 Best Automatic Fly Reels: Spring and Semi-Automatic

12 min read

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Read our affiliate disclosure.

The short answer

The Pflueger Automatic Fly Reel is the spring-wound 5/6 weight for boat and panfish anglers; the Maxcatch Automatic Fly Reel is a machined aluminum semi-automatic for 2 to 4 weight lines; and the Aventik Semi-Automatic Fly Reel is a 128-gram graphite semi-automatic at the entry tier.

Our verdict

Automatic Fly Reel Top Picks

An automatic fly reel winds line back without a handle, and two kinds answer this search. A spring automatic, like the Pflueger below or the Martin auto one r/flyfishing poster learned on, uses a main spring to wind line back while you hold a trigger. A semi-automatic has no spring: each pull of a lever turns the spool through a gear, and you pump it again for more line. We found four sold new and in stock on Amazon, from four makers, so this guide has four picks, not a padded ten. More gear is in our fishing gear section.

Reel finder

Find an automatic fly reel

Pick what you fish for and what you want to spend. The suggestion is our editorial starting point, drawn from the four reels below, not a test result.

How do you fish?
Price tier

Tiers are relative to the reels in this guide; live prices are in the comparison table below.

Compare the picks

Compare the 4 Automatic Fly Reels

Maker figures for the linked reel unless a cell names another source.

Pflueger Automatic Fly Reels, Size 44385 Fishing Reel…Pflueger AutomaticSpring-Wound 5/6 WeightBoats, panfishSpring5/6 wt$35.23 Prime
RetrieveSpring, line trigger
Line weight5/6 wt (listing says 7/8)
CapacityNot published
WeightListing: 11.2 oz
MaterialAluminum alloy, stainless spring

Evidence: a FishUSA customer review (shop site), model 1195X; one reviewer

Maxcatch Semi-Automatic Fly Fishing Reel, CNC Machine Cut…Maxcatch AutomaticMachined Semi-AutomaticTrout, fast waterLever and gears2-4 wt$149.99
RetrieveLever and gears, up to 2 m per pull
Capacity20 m of 20 lb backing
Weight146 g (5.15 oz)
MaterialCNC machined T6061 aluminum

Evidence: The Great Lakes of NYC fished the 2019 Maxcatch Automatic Reel; today's Black+Gunsmoke reel not confirmed the same

Aventik Automatic Fly Reel(Green) | Lightweight graphite…Aventik Semi-AutoGraphite Semi-AutomaticNymphing, troutLever and gears2-4 wt$39.99
RetrieveLever and gears, 2 m per pull
Capacity25 m of 20 lb backing
Weight128 g (4.52 oz)
MaterialGraphite

Evidence: maker specs only, no independent test

Semi-Automatic Fly Reel with Adjustable Drag Quick Spool…Bigchub Semi-AutoAluminum Semi-Auto, DragLakes, trout, streamsLeverNot published$54.99
RetrieveLever, adjustable drag
WeightListing: 174 g (6.14 oz)
MaterialCNC machined aluminum alloy

Evidence: maker specs only, no independent test

Prices as of Nov 18, 20:58 UTC

How We Picked These Automatic Reels

How this guide was built

built from manufacturer documentation, published third-party reviews and owner reports; we have not tested these products ourselves.

What each reel had to show

  • An automatic retrieve, by spring or lever, per the maker or listing.
  • Sold new and in stock on Amazon when we checked (14 November 2026), with the seller named in the review.
  • One slot per reel: Bigchub’s three colour listings are one reel.
  • Why four, not more: we checked every maker named by the pages that rank for this search (Pflueger, OCR Fly Reels, Peux, Soldarini, JMC, Franco Vivarelli and ATP) plus Martin and South Bend, with site searches of Amazon.com for each, Google’s first three pages of Amazon.com results for “automatic fly reel”, “semi automatic fly reel” and “spring fly reel”, and the first page of Amazon’s own results for “semi automatic fly reel”. The European and US-made semi-automatics turned up only at fly shops and maker stores, Martin and South Bend had no automatic there (see the FAQ), one unbranded semi-automatic had no current offer, and two unbranded “automatic” listings named no retrieve. Amazon’s own result pages 2 and 3 were not read.
Where the evidence comes from

Where the evidence comes from

We found no magazine test of these reels. The Pflueger has a FishUSA customer review (a buyer on a shop’s site). The Great Lakes of NYC, a New York fly-fishing blog whose author prefers Vivarelli reels, fished the 2019 Maxcatch beside a Vivarelli. Two r/flyfishing threads, on semi-automatic and automatic reels, give single posters’ views.

Automatic Fly Reels: Detailed Reviews

Pflueger Automatic Fly Reel, Spring-Wound 5/6 Weight

Spring-Wound 5/6 Weight
Pflueger Automatic Fly Reels, Size 44385 Fishing Reel…

Pflueger Automatic

Spring-Wound 5/6 Weight

Panfish and boat anglers on a 5 or 6 weight who want line back on the spool with one hand.

$35.23 from AmazonAs of Nov 18, 20:58 UTC

Verdict

The spring automatic of the four: a pull on the trigger winds line back, for anglers who need a free hand in a boat.

Evidence: No independent test; owner reports. FishUSA customer review: Pflueger Automatic 1195X.

Pflueger’s page lists model 1195X with a “Line Rating: 5 / 6 wt”, a right-hand position and “Drag Type: Spring”. It has an aluminum alloy frame and spool, a “Stainless steel main spring”, and a “Main spring release and fold down trigger for easy storage”. Pflueger pitches it for “use in boats where you need a free hand to paddle or pole”. It publishes no weight or capacity; the listing and FishUSA give 11.2 oz. Sources disagree on line rating: the Amazon listing for this 1195X says 7/8 and FishUSA “Up to 8”; we go by Pflueger’s 5/6.

A FishUSA customer, SkippyBrand, wrote in January 2024: “The automatic fly reel is handy when I fish for panfish that I simply strip in.” The review also warns to keep tension on the line. Two r/flyfishing posters name drawbacks of automatics. One who learned on a Martin, and liked it, “triggered the reel on my hook sets and pulled the hook out of the fishes lip”, and another calls the old ones “heavy, complicated, and easy to zing a small fish into your rod tip with”. Those posts are about other automatics, not this reel. Against the semi-automatics below, it takes heavier line than the Maxcatch and Aventik and keeps winding while you hold the trigger. Sold by Amazon.com, below Pflueger’s list price, at the time of writing.

Specs (linked: Pflueger Automatic Fly Reel, model 1195X, box packaging, right hand)

    Pros

    • Spring-wound trigger retrieve that frees a hand for a paddle or pole, per Pflueger
    • Aluminum alloy frame and spool with a stainless main spring, per Pflueger

    Cons

    • 11.2 oz per the listing, against 128 to 174 g for the semi-automatics here
    • Pflueger (5/6) and the Amazon listing (7/8) disagree on line rating

    Who should buy it

    Panfish and boat anglers on a 5 or 6 weight who want line back on the spool with one hand.

    Check on Amazon

    • Retrieve: spring, line trigger; main spring release (Pflueger)
    • Line rating: 5/6 wt (Pflueger); the listing says 7/8, FishUSA “Up to 8”
    • Weight: not published by Pflueger; 11.2 oz per the Amazon listing and FishUSA
    • Price tier: $ (live Amazon price in the table above)

    Maxcatch Automatic Fly Reel, Machined Semi-Automatic

    Machined Semi-Automatic
    Maxcatch Semi-Automatic Fly Fishing Reel, CNC Machine Cut…

    Maxcatch Automatic

    Machined Semi-Automatic

    Trout anglers on a 2 to 4 weight who want a machined semi-automatic from a brand storefront.

    $149.99 from AmazonAs of Nov 18, 20:58 UTC

    Verdict

    A CNC-machined lever semi-automatic for 2 to 4 weight lines; a blogger fished its 2019 version.

    Evidence: Independently reviewed, previous generation. The Great Lakes of NYC: Maxcatch Automatic Reel, 2019 version.

    Maxcatch’s page calls this lever reel the “Automatic Fly Reel”. It lists “CNC Machined T6061 Aluminum Construction”, a “pull-trigger system” that “Retrieves up to 2 meters of line per trigger pull”, 146 grams, and a “74mm outer diameter large arbor” for 2 to 4 weight lines and 20 m of 20 lb backing. Maxcatch does not describe the drag on that page or on Amazon.

    The Great Lakes of NYC fished a Maxcatch Automatic Reel beside a Vivarelli Goldstar in 2019. Today’s Black+Gunsmoke reel may differ from it. The blogger writes: “It has a removable spool and retrieves line with the touch of the lever.” He adds, “It has a cumbersome drag but it works,” and that “The Maxcatch has a small spool which prevents it from holding more than weight forward line #5.” He also faults the Phillips screws on the reel seat saddle: “It loosened several times while I fished.” Against the Aventik (#3), it is machined aluminum rather than graphite, at 18 grams more, and holds 5 m less backing, per the makers. Sold by Maxcatch Fishing and shipped by Amazon, at about 9% over Maxcatch’s own-site price when we checked (14 November 2026).

    Specs (linked: Maxcatch Automatic Fly Reel, Black+Gunsmoke)

      Pros

      • CNC-machined T6061 aluminum semi-automatic at 146 grams, per Maxcatch
      • Fished beside a Vivarelli by The Great Lakes of NYC (2019 version)

      Cons

      • Premium tier here, and above Maxcatch’s own-site price on Amazon when we checked
      • Small spool: the 2019 reel held no more than a WF5 line, per The Great Lakes of NYC
      • Saddle screws loosened on the 2019 reel, per The Great Lakes of NYC

      Who should buy it

      Trout anglers on a 2 to 4 weight who want a machined semi-automatic from a brand storefront.

      Check on Amazon

      • Retrieve: lever (pull-trigger) and gears, up to 2 m per pull (Maxcatch)
      • Line: 2-4 wt; 20 m of 20 lb backing; large arbor, 74 mm outer diameter (Maxcatch)
      • Weight: 146 g (5.15 oz) (Maxcatch)
      • Drag: not published (Maxcatch); the 2019 reel had an adjustable drag knob, per The Great Lakes of NYC
      • Price tier: $$$ (live Amazon price in the table above)

      Aventik Semi-Automatic Fly Reel, Graphite Semi-Automatic

      Graphite Semi-Automatic
      Aventik Automatic Fly Reel(Green) | Lightweight graphite…

      Aventik Semi-Auto

      Graphite Semi-Automatic

      Nymph and trout anglers on a 2 to 4 weight who want to try a semi-automatic at the entry tier.

      $39.99 from AmazonAs of Nov 18, 20:58 UTC

      Verdict

      A graphite lever semi-automatic for 2 to 4 weight lines, at 128 grams by Aventik’s figure and the entry tier of this guide.

      Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: Aventik.

      Aventik’s page lists 128 g, a “76mm Large Arbor”, 2-4 wt lines, 25 m of 20 lb backing and “2m Retrieval Per Cast” from a “Rapid Automatic Trigger System”, in four colours. The Amazon description adds that “An adjustable drag lets you fine-tune resistance” and a removable spool, and pitches it for nymph fishing and trout. One listing field says 220 g, likely the shipping weight; we use Aventik’s 128 g.

      We found no published test. Against the Maxcatch (#2): the same line range and 2 m per pull, in graphite, 18 grams lighter with 5 m more backing, per the makers; the Maxcatch has the 2019 blog report behind it. Sold by ANNESPORTS and shipped by Amazon, below Aventik’s regular price, when we checked.

      Specs (linked: Aventik Semi-Automatic Fly Reel, Green)

        Pros

        • 128-gram graphite body with a 76 mm large arbor spool, per Aventik
        • Adjustable drag and a removable spool, per the Amazon description

        Cons

        • Graphite rather than machined metal
        • No published test or owner report we could read
        • Sold by ANNESPORTS, a third-party seller

        Who should buy it

        Nymph and trout anglers on a 2 to 4 weight who want to try a semi-automatic at the entry tier.

        Check on Amazon

        • Retrieve: trigger lever and gears, 2 m per pull (Aventik)
        • Line: 2-4 wt; 25 m of 20 lb backing; large arbor, 76 mm (Aventik)
        • Weight: 128 g (4.52 oz) (Aventik); listing field says 220 g
        • Drag: adjustable, type not published (Amazon description)
        • Price tier: $ (live Amazon price in the table above)

        Bigchub Semi-Automatic Fly Reel, Aluminum Semi-Auto with Drag

        Aluminum Semi-Auto, Drag
        Semi-Automatic Fly Reel with Adjustable Drag Quick Spool…

        Bigchub Semi-Auto

        Aluminum Semi-Auto, Drag

        Lake and stream trout anglers who want an aluminum semi-automatic with a drag and can size the line themselves.

        $54.99 from AmazonAs of Nov 18, 20:58 UTC

        Verdict

        A CNC-machined aluminum lever reel with an adjustable drag and a quick-release spool, known only from its Amazon listing.

        Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: Bigchub Amazon listing.

        Bigchub’s Amazon listing (we found no Bigchub page outside Amazon) says the reel is “Made of CNC Machined Aluminum Alloy”, with a net weight of 174 grams (6.14 oz), a 75 mm diameter and an 18 mm spool width. It names a lever retrieve, “Adjustable Drag and Quick Spool Removal”, and anti-reverse. Bigchub publishes no line weight or backing capacity. The green and gunmetal versions are separate listings at 172 g and 168 g.

        We found no published test or readable owner report. Against the Maxcatch and Aventik: a similar 75 mm size, the only listing of the three that names anti-reverse, the heaviest on paper and no published line weight. Sold by saionline and shipped by Amazon, below the listing’s list price, when we checked.

        Specs (linked: Bigchub Semi-Automatic Fly Reel, black)

          Pros

          • CNC-machined aluminum semi-automatic with an adjustable drag, per the listing
          • Quick spool removal and anti-reverse, per the listing

          Cons

          • No published line weight or backing capacity
          • Sold by a third-party seller, saionline

          Who should buy it

          Lake and stream trout anglers who want an aluminum semi-automatic with a drag and can size the line themselves.

          Check on Amazon

          • Retrieve: lever; adjustable drag; anti-reverse; quick spool removal (Amazon listing)
          • Size: 75 mm diameter; 18 mm spool width (Amazon listing)
          • Line weight and backing: not published
          • Weight: 174 g (6.14 oz) (Amazon listing)
          • Price tier: $$ (live Amazon price in the table above)

          Automatic or Semi-Automatic: How to Choose

          Spring automatics: hold the trigger

          A spring automatic winds as long as you hold the lever, because, in one r/flyfishing poster’s words, “it is a loaded spring that turns the spook” (spool). Another poster, in a semi-automatic thread, says old timers on Michigan’s Au Sable still run them while poling a river boat. The Pflueger weighs 11.2 oz by its listing, so check the balance on your rod (our fly reel weight guide explains why it matters). The poster who pulled hooks with a Martin fixed it by strip-setting.

          Spring automatic and semi-automatic fly reels
          Illustration: a spring automatic beside a lever semi-automatic

          Semi-automatic fly reels: pump the lever

          A semi-automatic turns the spool through gears each time you pull the lever. 1000flies, a shop that sells them, says “One stroke of the lever generally corresponds to four complete turns of the spool.” It adds that “Classic semi-automatic reels have neither drags nor reel handles”; the Aventik and Bigchub listings name an adjustable drag. 1000flies names Franco Vivarelli, founded in 1982, among “the pioneers”. Vivarelli, JMC, Soldarini, Peux and OCR’s Wyoming-made Bighorn turned up at fly shops and maker stores, not on Amazon.com, when we checked.

          Line weight, spool and backing

          Maxcatch and Aventik list 2 to 4 weight lines, Bigchub lists none, and Pflueger rates its reel 5/6: match the reel to your rod with our fly reel size guide. Backing is 20 m (Maxcatch) or 25 m (Aventik) of 20 lb, per the makers; our guide to putting backing on a fly reel covers loading it. For a big spool and heavier lines, see our large arbor fly reels, which share no picks with this guide.

          Drag and playing fish

          None of the four makers names a disc drag: Pflueger lists a spring drag, and the Aventik and Bigchub listings an adjustable one of unstated type. For manual reels, see our click and pawl fly reels explainer. 1000flies’ advice for semi-automatics: “If you play a fish, we recommend to retrieve it by hand and to use the lever just to wind up the slack line.”

          Frequently Asked Questions

          Q. Are automatic fly reels good?

          Opinions split on r/flyfishing. One poster’s uncle, with little use of one hand, can fly fish with one; a poster (TglofNYC, likely the Maxcatch blogger) who has used semi-automatics since 1983 calls them “more efficient than traditional fly reels, especially for massive fish, like carp or pike”. Another quit his for a manual reel and calls the old spring ones heavy.

          Q. Are there automatic fishing reels?

          Yes: Pflueger’s spring-wound Automatic Fly Reel, and lever semi-automatics like the Maxcatch, Aventik and Bigchub.

          Q. What about Martin and South Bend automatic reels?

          We found neither sold new as an automatic on Amazon when we checked: Martin’s Amazon reels were single-action click models and South Bend showed only parts. The new spring automatic we found is Pflueger’s 1195X.

          Q. Is a semi-automatic reel good for euro nymphing?

          Aventik pitches its reel for nymph fishing, and one r/flyfishing poster says he uses a semi-automatic for euro nymphing. For the line, see our fly lines for nymphing.

          Q. What is the best fly reel for the money?

          Within this type, the Aventik and Pflueger sit at the entry tier by their makers’ regular prices. For fly reels in general, the picks are in our large arbor fly reel guide.

          The bottom line

          Final Verdict

          For one-handed pickup in a boat, the Pflueger Automatic Fly Reel (check price) is the spring-wound 5/6 weight, sold by Amazon.com. For light lines, the Maxcatch Automatic Fly Reel (check price) is the machined semi-automatic with a 2019 blog report on its earlier version, the Aventik Semi-Automatic Fly Reel (check price) is the 128-gram graphite option at the entry tier, and the Bigchub Semi-Automatic Fly Reel (check price) adds a listed drag and anti-reverse but publishes no line weight. More gear is in our fishing gear section.

          Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

          Outgearly Team
          Outgearly Team

          Written and reviewed by the Outgearly Team. See the About page for how we work.